IN RE: NC SWINE FARM NUISANCE LITIGATION. THIS DOCUMENT RELATES TO: ALL CASES Master Case No. 5:15-CV-00013-BR United States District Court, E.D. North Carolina Signed July 01, 2016 Counsel Smithfield Foods, Inc., Movant, represented by Mark E. Anderson, McGuireWoods LLP. All Plaintiffs, Plaintiff, represented by Eric Manchin, Kaeske Law Firm, John S. Hughes, Wallace and Graham, P.A., Lynn Bradshaw, Kaeske Law Firm, Michael Kaeske, Jr., Kaeske Law Firm & Mona Lisa Wallace, Wallace and Graham, P.A.. Betty Collier, Plaintiff, represented by Eric Manchin, Kaeske Law Firm, John S. Hughes, Wallace and Graham, P.A., Lynn Bradshaw, Kaeske Law Firm, Michael Kaeske, Jr., Kaeske Law Firm & Mona Lisa Wallace, Wallace and Graham, P.A.. Andrew High, Plaintiff, represented by Eric Manchin, Kaeske Law Firm, John S. Hughes, Wallace and Graham, P.A., Lynn Bradshaw, Kaeske Law Firm, Michael Kaeske, Jr., Kaeske Law Firm & Mona Lisa Wallace, Wallace and Graham, P.A.. Alice High, Plaintiff, represented by Eric Manchin, Kaeske Law Firm, John S. Hughes, Wallace and Graham, P.A., Lynn Bradshaw, Kaeske Law Firm, Michael Kaeske, Jr., Kaeske Law Firm & Mona Lisa Wallace, Wallace and Graham, P.A.. Antwan High, Plaintiff, represented by Eric Manchin, Kaeske Law Firm, John S. Hughes, Wallace and Graham, P.A., Lynn Bradshaw, Kaeske Law Firm, Michael Kaeske, Jr., Kaeske Law Firm & Mona Lisa Wallace, Wallace and Graham, P.A.. Rosalyn Moore, Plaintiff, represented by Eric Manchin, Kaeske Law Firm, John S. Hughes, Wallace and Graham, P.A., Lynn Bradshaw, Kaeske Law Firm, Michael Kaeske, Jr., Kaeske Law Firm & Mona Lisa Wallace, Wallace and Graham, P.A.. Lorrine Robinson, Plaintiff, represented by Eric Manchin, Kaeske Law Firm, John S. Hughes, Wallace and Graham, P.A., Lynn Bradshaw, Kaeske Law Firm, Michael Kaeske, Jr., Kaeske Law Firm & Mona Lisa Wallace, Wallace and Graham, P.A.. Anthony Robinson, Plaintiff, represented by Eric Manchin, Kaeske Law Firm, John S. Hughes, Wallace and Graham, P.A., Lynn Bradshaw, Kaeske Law Firm, Michael Kaeske, Jr., Kaeske Law Firm & Mona Lisa Wallace, Wallace and Graham, P.A.. Gwendolyn High, Plaintiff, represented by Eric Manchin, Kaeske Law Firm, John S. Hughes, Wallace and Graham, P.A., Lynn Bradshaw, Kaeske Law Firm, Michael Kaeske, Jr., Kaeske Law Firm & Mona Lisa Wallace, Wallace and Graham, P.A.. Angela High, Plaintiff, represented by Eric Manchin, Kaeske Law Firm, John S. Hughes, Wallace and Graham, P.A., Lynn Bradshaw, Kaeske Law Firm, Michael Kaeske, Jr., Kaeske Law Firm & Mona Lisa Wallace, Wallace and Graham, P.A.. Cynthia High, Plaintiff, represented by Eric Manchin, Kaeske Law Firm, John S. Hughes, Wallace and Graham, P.A., Lynn Bradshaw, Kaeske Law Firm, Michael Kaeske, Jr., Kaeske Law Firm & Mona Lisa Wallace, Wallace and Graham, P.A.. Eric High, Plaintiff, represented by Eric Manchin, Kaeske Law Firm, John S. Hughes, Wallace and Graham, P.A., Lynn Bradshaw, Kaeske Law Firm, Michael Kaeske, Jr., Kaeske Law Firm & Mona Lisa Wallace, Wallace and Graham, P.A.. Ledesmond High, Plaintiff, represented by Eric Manchin, Kaeske Law Firm, John S. Hughes, Wallace and Graham, P.A., Lynn Bradshaw, Kaeske Law Firm, Michael Kaeske, Jr., Kaeske Law Firm & Mona Lisa Wallace, Wallace and Graham, P.A.. Titus High, Plaintiff, represented by Eric Manchin, Kaeske Law Firm, John S. Hughes, Wallace and Graham, P.A., Lynn Bradshaw, Kaeske Law Firm, Michael Kaeske, Jr., Kaeske Law Firm & Mona Lisa Wallace, Wallace and Graham, P.A.. Jacqueline High, Plaintiff, represented by Eric Manchin, Kaeske Law Firm, John S. Hughes, Wallace and Graham, P.A., Lynn Bradshaw, Kaeske Law Firm, Michael Kaeske, Jr., Kaeske Law Firm & Mona Lisa Wallace, Wallace and Graham, P.A.. Margaret Greta Nicholson, Plaintiff, represented by Eric Manchin, Kaeske Law Firm, John S. Hughes, Wallace and Graham, P.A., Lynn Bradshaw, Kaeske Law Firm, Michael Kaeske, Jr., Kaeske Law Firm & Mona Lisa Wallace, Wallace and Graham, P.A.. Judith Worrell, Plaintiff, represented by Eric Manchin, Kaeske Law Firm, John S. Hughes, Wallace and Graham, P.A., Lynn Bradshaw, Kaeske Law Firm, Michael Kaeske, Jr., Kaeske Law Firm & Mona Lisa Wallace, Wallace and Graham, P.A.. Little Worrell, Plaintiff, represented by Eric Manchin, Kaeske Law Firm, John S. Hughes, Wallace and Graham, P.A., Lynn Bradshaw, Kaeske Law Firm, Michael Kaeske, Jr., Kaeske Law Firm & Mona Lisa Wallace, Wallace and Graham, P.A.. Iris High, Plaintiff, represented by Eric Manchin, Kaeske Law Firm, John S. Hughes, Wallace and Graham, P.A., Lynn Bradshaw, Kaeske Law Firm, Michael Kaeske, Jr., Kaeske Law Firm & Mona Lisa Wallace, Wallace and Graham, P.A.. Elsie Hockaday, Plaintiff, represented by Eric Manchin, Kaeske Law Firm, John S. Hughes, Wallace and Graham, P.A., Lynn Bradshaw, Kaeske Law Firm, Michael Kaeske, Jr., Kaeske Law Firm & Mona Lisa Wallace, Wallace and Graham, P.A.. John Hockaday, Plaintiff, represented by Eric Manchin, Kaeske Law Firm, John S. Hughes, Wallace and Graham, P.A., Lynn Bradshaw, Kaeske Law Firm, Michael Kaeske, Jr., Kaeske Law Firm & Mona Lisa Wallace, Wallace and Graham, P.A.. Lakechia Turner, Plaintiff, represented by Eric Manchin, Kaeske Law Firm, John S. Hughes, Wallace and Graham, P.A., Lynn Bradshaw, Kaeske Law Firm, Michael Kaeske, Jr., Kaeske Law Firm & Mona Lisa Wallace, Wallace and Graham, P.A.. Kentrel Davis, Plaintiff, represented by Eric Manchin, Kaeske Law Firm, John S. Hughes, Wallace and Graham, P.A., Lynn Bradshaw, Kaeske Law Firm, Michael Kaeske, Jr., Kaeske Law Firm & Mona Lisa Wallace, Wallace and Graham, P.A.. Erma Jean Miles, Plaintiff, represented by Eric Manchin, Kaeske Law Firm, John S. Hughes, Wallace and Graham, P.A., Lynn Bradshaw, Kaeske Law Firm, Michael Kaeske, Jr., Kaeske Law Firm & Mona Lisa Wallace, Wallace and Graham, P.A.. Notis Holt, Plaintiff, represented by Eric Manchin, Kaeske Law Firm, John S. Hughes, Wallace and Graham, P.A., Lynn Bradshaw, Kaeske Law Firm, Michael Kaeske, Jr., Kaeske Law Firm & Mona Lisa Wallace, Wallace and Graham, P.A.. John Lashley, Plaintiff, represented by Eric Manchin, Kaeske Law Firm, John S. Hughes, Wallace and Graham, P.A., Lynn Bradshaw, Kaeske Law Firm, Michael Kaeske, Jr., Kaeske Law Firm & Mona Lisa Wallace, Wallace and Graham, P.A.. Melvin Lashley, Plaintiff, represented by Eric Manchin, Kaeske Law Firm, John S. Hughes, Wallace and Graham, P.A., Lynn Bradshaw, Kaeske Law Firm, Michael Kaeske, Jr., Kaeske Law Firm & Mona Lisa Wallace, Wallace and Graham, P.A.. James Lashley, Plaintiff, represented by Eric Manchin, Kaeske Law Firm, John S. Hughes, Wallace and Graham, P.A., Lynn Bradshaw, Kaeske Law Firm, Michael Kaeske, Jr., Kaeske Law Firm & Mona Lisa Wallace, Wallace and Graham, P.A.. Hattie Tucker, Plaintiff, represented by Eric Manchin, Kaeske Law Firm, John S. Hughes, Wallace and Graham, P.A., Lynn Bradshaw, Kaeske Law Firm, Michael Kaeske, Jr., Kaeske Law Firm & Mona Lisa Wallace, Wallace and Graham, P.A.. Leroy Broadie, Plaintiff, represented by Eric Manchin, Kaeske Law Firm, John S. Hughes, Wallace and Graham, P.A., Lynn Bradshaw, Kaeske Law Firm, Michael Kaeske, Jr., Kaeske Law Firm & Mona Lisa Wallace, Wallace and Graham, P.A.. Michelle Garner, Plaintiff, represented by Eric Manchin, Kaeske Law Firm, John S. Hughes, Wallace and Graham, P.A., Lynn Bradshaw, Kaeske Law Firm, Michael Kaeske, Jr., Kaeske Law Firm & Mona Lisa Wallace, Wallace and Graham, P.A.. Brenda Garner Bing, Plaintiff, represented by Eric Manchin, Kaeske Law Firm, John S. Hughes, Wallace and Graham, P.A., Lynn Bradshaw, Kaeske Law Firm, Michael Kaeske, Jr., Kaeske Law Firm & Mona Lisa Wallace, Wallace and Graham, P.A.. Ricky Lee Gray, Plaintiff, represented by Eric Manchin, Kaeske Law Firm, John S. Hughes, Wallace and Graham, P.A., Lynn Bradshaw, Kaeske Law Firm, Michael Kaeske, Jr., Kaeske Law Firm & Mona Lisa Wallace, Wallace and Graham, P.A.. Belinda Deborah Boone, Plaintiff, represented by Eric Manchin, Kaeske Law Firm, John S. Hughes, Wallace and Graham, P.A., Lynn Bradshaw, Kaeske Law Firm, Michael Kaeske, Jr., Kaeske Law Firm & Mona Lisa Wallace, Wallace and Graham, P.A.. Tracey Scott Godley, Plaintiff, represented by Eric Manchin, Kaeske Law Firm, John S. Hughes, Wallace and Graham, P.A., Lynn Bradshaw, Kaeske Law Firm, Michael Kaeske, Jr., Kaeske Law Firm & Mona Lisa Wallace, Wallace and Graham, P.A.. Mary Ethel Adams, Plaintiff, represented by Eric Manchin, Kaeske Law Firm, John S. Hughes, Wallace and Graham, P.A., Lynn Bradshaw, Kaeske Law Firm, Michael Kaeske, Jr., Kaeske Law Firm & Mona Lisa Wallace, Wallace and Graham, P.A.. Walter Guy Adams, Plaintiff, represented by Eric Manchin, Kaeske Law Firm, John S. Hughes, Wallace and Graham, P.A., Lynn Bradshaw, Kaeske Law Firm, Michael Kaeske, Jr., Kaeske Law Firm & Mona Lisa Wallace, Wallace and Graham, P.A.. Michael Johnson, Plaintiff, represented by Eric Manchin, Kaeske Law Firm, John S. Hughes, Wallace and Graham, P.A., Lynn Bradshaw, Kaeske Law Firm, Michael Kaeske, Jr., Kaeske Law Firm & Mona Lisa Wallace, Wallace and Graham, P.A.. Rudolph Adams, Plaintiff, represented by Eric Manchin, Kaeske Law Firm, John S. Hughes, Wallace and Graham, P.A., Lynn Bradshaw, Kaeske Law Firm, Michael Kaeske, Jr., Kaeske Law Firm & Mona Lisa Wallace, Wallace and Graham, P.A.. Carolyn Adams, Plaintiff, represented by Eric Manchin, Kaeske Law Firm, John S. Hughes, Wallace and Graham, P.A., Lynn Bradshaw, Kaeske Law Firm, Michael Kaeske, Jr., Kaeske Law Firm & Mona Lisa Wallace, Wallace and Graham, P.A.. Margaret Stewart Adams, Plaintiff, represented by Eric Manchin, Kaeske Law Firm, John S. Hughes, Wallace and Graham, P.A., Lynn Bradshaw, Kaeske Law Firm, Michael Kaeske, Jr., Kaeske Law Firm & Mona Lisa Wallace, Wallace and Graham, P.A.. Phyllis Monte Adams, Plaintiff, represented by Eric Manchin, Kaeske Law Firm, John S. Hughes, Wallace and Graham, P.A., Lynn Bradshaw, Kaeske Law Firm, Michael Kaeske, Jr., Kaeske Law Firm & Mona Lisa Wallace, Wallace and Graham, P.A.. Lois Stewart Banks, Plaintiff, represented by Eric Manchin, Kaeske Law Firm, John S. Hughes, Wallace and Graham, P.A., Lynn Bradshaw, Kaeske Law Firm, Michael Kaeske, Jr., Kaeske Law Firm & Mona Lisa Wallace, Wallace and Graham, P.A.. John Everett, Plaintiff, represented by Eric Manchin, Kaeske Law Firm, John S. Hughes, Wallace and Graham, P.A., Lynn Bradshaw, Kaeske Law Firm, Michael Kaeske, Jr., Kaeske Law Firm & Mona Lisa Wallace, Wallace and Graham, P.A.. Regina Everett, Plaintiff, represented by Eric Manchin, Kaeske Law Firm, John S. Hughes, Wallace and Graham, P.A., Lynn Bradshaw, Kaeske Law Firm, Michael Kaeske, Jr., Kaeske Law Firm & Mona Lisa Wallace, Wallace and Graham, P.A.. Shannon Adams, Plaintiff, represented by Eric Manchin, Kaeske Law Firm, John S. Hughes, Wallace and Graham, P.A., Lynn Bradshaw, Kaeske Law Firm, Michael Kaeske, Jr., Kaeske Law Firm & Mona Lisa Wallace, Wallace and Graham, P.A.. Sharon Robinson, Plaintiff, represented by Eric Manchin, Kaeske Law Firm, John S. Hughes, Wallace and Graham, P.A., Lynn Bradshaw, Kaeske Law Firm, Michael Kaeske, Jr., Kaeske Law Firm & Mona Lisa Wallace, Wallace and Graham, P.A.. Don Webb, Plaintiff, represented by Eric Manchin, Kaeske Law Firm, John S. Hughes, Wallace and Graham, P.A., Lynn Bradshaw, Kaeske Law Firm, Michael Kaeske, Jr., Kaeske Law Firm & Mona Lisa Wallace, Wallace and Graham, P.A.. Susan Webb, Plaintiff, represented by Eric Manchin, Kaeske Law Firm, John S. Hughes, Wallace and Graham, P.A., Lynn Bradshaw, Kaeske Law Firm, Michael Kaeske, Jr., Kaeske Law Firm & Mona Lisa Wallace, Wallace and Graham, P.A.. Isaac Ward, Plaintiff, represented by Eric Manchin, Kaeske Law Firm, John S. Hughes, Wallace and Graham, P.A., Lynn Bradshaw, Kaeske Law Firm, Michael Kaeske, Jr., Kaeske Law Firm & Mona Lisa Wallace, Wallace and Graham, P.A.. Randy Davis, Plaintiff, represented by Eric Manchin, Kaeske Law Firm, John S. Hughes, Wallace and Graham, P.A., Lynn Bradshaw, Kaeske Law Firm, Michael Kaeske, Jr., Kaeske Law Firm & Mona Lisa Wallace, Wallace and Graham, P.A.. Julie Davis, Plaintiff, represented by Eric Manchin, Kaeske Law Firm, John S. Hughes, Wallace and Graham, P.A., Lynn Bradshaw, Kaeske Law Firm, Michael Kaeske, Jr., Kaeske Law Firm & Mona Lisa Wallace, Wallace and Graham, P.A.. Lillie Davis, Plaintiff, represented by Eric Manchin, Kaeske Law Firm, John S. Hughes, Wallace and Graham, P.A., Lynn Bradshaw, Kaeske Law Firm, Michael Kaeske, Jr., Kaeske Law Firm & Mona Lisa Wallace, Wallace and Graham, P.A.. Luke Davis, Plaintiff, represented by Eric Manchin, Kaeske Law Firm, John S. Hughes, Wallace and Graham, P.A., Lynn Bradshaw, Kaeske Law Firm, Michael Kaeske, Jr., Kaeske Law Firm & Mona Lisa Wallace, Wallace and Graham, P.A.. Lloyd Davis, Plaintiff, represented by Eric Manchin, Kaeske Law Firm, John S. Hughes, Wallace and Graham, P.A., Lynn Bradshaw, Kaeske Law Firm, Michael Kaeske, Jr., Kaeske Law Firm & Mona Lisa Wallace, Wallace and Graham, P.A.. Jennie Davis, Plaintiff, represented by Eric Manchin, Kaeske Law Firm, John S. Hughes, Wallace and Graham, P.A., Lynn Bradshaw, Kaeske Law Firm, Michael Kaeske, Jr., Kaeske Law Firm & Mona Lisa Wallace, Wallace and Graham, P.A.. Dennis Best, Plaintiff, represented by Eric Manchin, Kaeske Law Firm, John S. Hughes, Wallace and Graham, P.A., Lynn Bradshaw, Kaeske Law Firm, Michael Kaeske, Jr., Kaeske Law Firm & Mona Lisa Wallace, Wallace and Graham, P.A.. Kelly Best, Plaintiff, represented by Eric Manchin, Kaeske Law Firm, John S. Hughes, Wallace and Graham, P.A., Lynn Bradshaw, Kaeske Law Firm, Michael Kaeske, Jr., Kaeske Law Firm & Mona Lisa Wallace, Wallace and Graham, P.A.. Dennis D Best, Plaintiff, represented by Eric Manchin, Kaeske Law Firm, John S. Hughes, Wallace and Graham, P.A., Lynn Bradshaw, Kaeske Law Firm, Michael Kaeske, Jr., Kaeske Law Firm & Mona Lisa Wallace, Wallace and Graham, P.A.. Ethel Best, Plaintiff, represented by Eric Manchin, Kaeske Law Firm, John S. Hughes, Wallace and Graham, P.A., Lynn Bradshaw, Kaeske Law Firm, Michael Kaeske, Jr., Kaeske Law Firm & Mona Lisa Wallace, Wallace and Graham, P.A.. Buddy Joyner, Plaintiff, represented by Eric Manchin, Kaeske Law Firm, John S. Hughes, Wallace and Graham, P.A., Lynn Bradshaw, Kaeske Law Firm, Michael Kaeske, Jr., Kaeske Law Firm & Mona Lisa Wallace, Wallace and Graham, P.A.. Katie Joyner, Plaintiff, represented by Eric Manchin, Kaeske Law Firm, John S. Hughes, Wallace and Graham, P.A., Lynn Bradshaw, Kaeske Law Firm, Michael Kaeske, Jr., Kaeske Law Firm & Mona Lisa Wallace, Wallace and Graham, P.A.. Jeremiah Mathewson, Plaintiff, represented by Eric Manchin, Kaeske Law Firm, John S. Hughes, Wallace and Graham, P.A., Lynn Bradshaw, Kaeske Law Firm, Michael Kaeske, Jr., Kaeske Law Firm & Mona Lisa Wallace, Wallace and Graham, P.A.. Susan Mathewson, Plaintiff, represented by Eric Manchin, Kaeske Law Firm, John S. Hughes, Wallace and Graham, P.A., Lynn Bradshaw, Kaeske Law Firm, Michael Kaeske, Jr., Kaeske Law Firm & Mona Lisa Wallace, Wallace and Graham, P.A.. Kevin Pierce, Plaintiff, represented by Eric Manchin, Kaeske Law Firm, John S. Hughes, Wallace and Graham, P.A., Lynn Bradshaw, Kaeske Law Firm, Michael Kaeske, Jr., Kaeske Law Firm & Mona Lisa Wallace, Wallace and Graham, P.A.. Tanner Pierce, Plaintiff, represented by Eric Manchin, Kaeske Law Firm, John S. Hughes, Wallace and Graham, P.A., Lynn Bradshaw, Kaeske Law Firm, Michael Kaeske, Jr., Kaeske Law Firm & Mona Lisa Wallace, Wallace and Graham, P.A.. Mindy Pierce, Plaintiff, represented by Eric Manchin, Kaeske Law Firm, John S. Hughes, Wallace and Graham, P.A., Lynn Bradshaw, Kaeske Law Firm, Michael Kaeske, Jr., Kaeske Law Firm & Mona Lisa Wallace, Wallace and Graham, P.A.. Manuel Raya, Plaintiff, represented by Eric Manchin, Kaeske Law Firm, John S. Hughes, Wallace and Graham, P.A., Lynn Bradshaw, Kaeske Law Firm, Michael Kaeske, Jr., Kaeske Law Firm & Mona Lisa Wallace, Wallace and Graham, P.A.. Gabriella Raya, Plaintiff, represented by Eric Manchin, Kaeske Law Firm, John S. Hughes, Wallace and Graham, P.A., Lynn Bradshaw, Kaeske Law Firm, Michael Kaeske, Jr., Kaeske Law Firm & Mona Lisa Wallace, Wallace and Graham, P.A.. Victor Raya, Plaintiff, represented by Eric Manchin, Kaeske Law Firm, John S. Hughes, Wallace and Graham, P.A., Lynn Bradshaw, Kaeske Law Firm, Michael Kaeske, Jr., Kaeske Law Firm & Mona Lisa Wallace, Wallace and Graham, P.A.. Olivia Raya, Plaintiff, represented by Eric Manchin, Kaeske Law Firm, John S. Hughes, Wallace and Graham, P.A., Lynn Bradshaw, Kaeske Law Firm, Michael Kaeske, Jr., Kaeske Law Firm & Mona Lisa Wallace, Wallace and Graham, P.A.. Gene Pearson, Plaintiff, represented by Eric Manchin, Kaeske Law Firm, John S. Hughes, Wallace and Graham, P.A., Lynn Bradshaw, Kaeske Law Firm, Michael Kaeske, Jr., Kaeske Law Firm & Mona Lisa Wallace, Wallace and Graham, P.A.. Edith Pearson, Plaintiff, represented by Eric Manchin, Kaeske Law Firm, John S. Hughes, Wallace and Graham, P.A., Lynn Bradshaw, Kaeske Law Firm, Michael Kaeske, Jr., Kaeske Law Firm & Mona Lisa Wallace, Wallace and Graham, P.A.. Kelly Pearson, Plaintiff, represented by Eric Manchin, Kaeske Law Firm, John S. Hughes, Wallace and Graham, P.A., Lynn Bradshaw, Kaeske Law Firm, Michael Kaeske, Jr., Kaeske Law Firm & Mona Lisa Wallace, Wallace and Graham, P.A.. Deborah R. Wolfe, Plaintiff, represented by Eric Manchin, Kaeske Law Firm, John S. Hughes, Wallace and Graham, P.A., Lynn Bradshaw, Kaeske Law Firm, Michael Kaeske, Jr., Kaeske Law Firm & Mona Lisa Wallace, Wallace and Graham, P.A.. Joyce McKiver, Plaintiff, represented by Eric Manchin, Kaeske Law Firm, John S. Hughes, Wallace and Graham, P.A., Lynn Bradshaw, Kaeske Law Firm, Michael Kaeske, Jr., Kaeske Law Firm & Mona Lisa Wallace, Wallace and Graham, P.A.. Delois Lewis, Plaintiff, represented by Eric Manchin, Kaeske Law Firm, John S. Hughes, Wallace and Graham, P.A., Lynn Bradshaw, Kaeske Law Firm, Michael Kaeske, Jr., Kaeske Law Firm & Mona Lisa Wallace, Wallace and Graham, P.A.. Dennis McKiver, Jr., Plaintiff, represented by Eric Manchin, Kaeske Law Firm, John S. Hughes, Wallace and Graham, P.A., Lynn Bradshaw, Kaeske Law Firm, Michael Kaeske, Jr., Kaeske Law Firm & Mona Lisa Wallace, Wallace and Graham, P.A.. LaJune Jessup, Plaintiff, represented by Eric Manchin, Kaeske Law Firm, John S. Hughes, Wallace and Graham, P.A., Lynn Bradshaw, Kaeske Law Firm, Michael Kaeske, Jr., Kaeske Law Firm & Mona Lisa Wallace, Wallace and Graham, P.A.. Daphne McKoy, Plaintiff, represented by Eric Manchin, Kaeske Law Firm, John S. Hughes, Wallace and Graham, P.A., Lynn Bradshaw, Kaeske Law Firm, Michael Kaeske, Jr., Kaeske Law Firm & Mona Lisa Wallace, Wallace and Graham, P.A.. Alexandria McKoy, Plaintiff, represented by Eric Manchin, Kaeske Law Firm, John S. Hughes, Wallace and Graham, P.A., Lynn Bradshaw, Kaeske Law Firm, Michael Kaeske, Jr., Kaeske Law Firm & Mona Lisa Wallace, Wallace and Graham, P.A.. Antonio McKoy, Plaintiff, represented by Eric Manchin, Kaeske Law Firm, John S. Hughes, Wallace and Graham, P.A., Lynn Bradshaw, Kaeske Law Firm, Michael Kaeske, Jr., Kaeske Law Firm & Mona Lisa Wallace, Wallace and Graham, P.A.. Fred Lloyd, Plaintiff, represented by Eric Manchin, Kaeske Law Firm, John S. Hughes, Wallace and Graham, P.A., Lynn Bradshaw, Kaeske Law Firm, Michael Kaeske, Jr., Kaeske Law Firm & Mona Lisa Wallace, Wallace and Graham, P.A.. Archie Wright, Jr., Plaintiff, represented by Eric Manchin, Kaeske Law Firm, John S. Hughes, Wallace and Graham, P.A., Lynn Bradshaw, Kaeske Law Firm, Michael Kaeske, Jr., Kaeske Law Firm & Mona Lisa Wallace, Wallace and Graham, P.A.. Teresa Lloyd, Plaintiff, represented by Eric Manchin, Kaeske Law Firm, John S. Hughes, Wallace and Graham, P.A., Lynn Bradshaw, Kaeske Law Firm, Michael Kaeske, Jr., Kaeske Law Firm & Mona Lisa Wallace, Wallace and Graham, P.A.. Tammy Lloyd, Plaintiff, represented by Eric Manchin, Kaeske Law Firm, John S. Hughes, Wallace and Graham, P.A., Lynn Bradshaw, Kaeske Law Firm, Michael Kaeske, Jr., Kaeske Law Firm & Mona Lisa Wallace, Wallace and Graham, P.A.. Tanechia Lloyd, Plaintiff, represented by Eric Manchin, Kaeske Law Firm, John S. Hughes, Wallace and Graham, P.A., Lynn Bradshaw, Kaeske Law Firm, Michael Kaeske, Jr., Kaeske Law Firm & Mona Lisa Wallace, Wallace and Graham, P.A.. Deborah Johnson, Plaintiff, represented by Eric Manchin, Kaeske Law Firm, John S. Hughes, Wallace and Graham, P.A., Lynn Bradshaw, Kaeske Law Firm, Michael Kaeske, Jr., Kaeske Law Firm & Mona Lisa Wallace, Wallace and Graham, P.A.. Ethel Davis, Plaintiff, represented by Eric Manchin, Kaeske Law Firm, John S. Hughes, Wallace and Graham, P.A., Lynn Bradshaw, Kaeske Law Firm, Michael Kaeske, Jr., Kaeske Law Firm & Mona Lisa Wallace, Wallace and Graham, P.A.. Priscilla Dunham, Plaintiff, represented by Eric Manchin, Kaeske Law Firm, John S. Hughes, Wallace and Graham, P.A., Lynn Bradshaw, Kaeske Law Firm, Michael Kaeske, Jr., Kaeske Law Firm & Mona Lisa Wallace, Wallace and Graham, P.A.. Carl Lewis, Plaintiff, represented by Eric Manchin, Kaeske Law Firm, John S. Hughes, Wallace and Graham, P.A., Lynn Bradshaw, Kaeske Law Firm, Michael Kaeske, Jr., Kaeske Law Firm & Mona Lisa Wallace, Wallace and Graham, P.A.. Annette McKiver, Plaintiff, represented by Eric Manchin, Kaeske Law Firm, John S. Hughes, Wallace and Graham, P.A., Lynn Bradshaw, Kaeske Law Firm, Michael Kaeske, Jr., Kaeske Law Firm & Mona Lisa Wallace, Wallace and Graham, P.A.. Karen McKiver, Plaintiff, represented by Eric Manchin, Kaeske Law Firm, John S. Hughes, Wallace and Graham, P.A., Lynn Bradshaw, Kaeske Law Firm, Michael Kaeske, Jr., Kaeske Law Firm & Mona Lisa Wallace, Wallace and Graham, P.A.. Brionna McKiver, Plaintiff, represented by Eric Manchin, Kaeske Law Firm, John S. Hughes, Wallace and Graham, P.A., Lynn Bradshaw, Kaeske Law Firm, Michael Kaeske, Jr., Kaeske Law Firm & Mona Lisa Wallace, Wallace and Graham, P.A.. Edward Owens, Plaintiff, represented by Eric Manchin, Kaeske Law Firm, John S. Hughes, Wallace and Graham, P.A., Lynn Bradshaw, Kaeske Law Firm, Michael Kaeske, Jr., Kaeske Law Firm & Mona Lisa Wallace, Wallace and Graham, P.A.. Daisy Lloyd, Plaintiff, represented by Eric Manchin, Kaeske Law Firm, John S. Hughes, Wallace and Graham, P.A., Lynn Bradshaw, Kaeske Law Firm, Michael Kaeske, Jr., Kaeske Law Firm & Mona Lisa Wallace, Wallace and Graham, P.A.. Pamela Kaye McMillon, Plaintiff, represented by Eric Manchin, Kaeske Law Firm, John S. Hughes, Wallace and Graham, P.A., Lynn Bradshaw, Kaeske Law Firm, Michael Kaeske, Jr., Kaeske Law Firm & Mona Lisa Wallace, Wallace and Graham, P.A.. Joe E. Powell, Jr., Plaintiff, represented by Eric Manchin, Kaeske Law Firm, John S. Hughes, Wallace and Graham, P.A., Lynn Bradshaw, Kaeske Law Firm, Michael Kaeske, Jr., Kaeske Law Firm & Mona Lisa Wallace, Wallace and Graham, P.A.. Rededieth Morrissey, Plaintiff, represented by Eric Manchin, Kaeske Law Firm, John S. Hughes, Wallace and Graham, P.A., Lynn Bradshaw, Kaeske Law Firm, Michael Kaeske, Jr., Kaeske Law Firm & Mona Lisa Wallace, Wallace and Graham, P.A.. Timothy Morrissey, Plaintiff, represented by Eric Manchin, Kaeske Law Firm, John S. Hughes, Wallace and Graham, P.A., Lynn Bradshaw, Kaeske Law Firm, Michael Kaeske, Jr., Kaeske Law Firm & Mona Lisa Wallace, Wallace and Graham, P.A.. Marilyn Alderman, Plaintiff, represented by Eric Manchin, Kaeske Law Firm, John S. Hughes, Wallace and Graham, P.A., Lynn Bradshaw, Kaeske Law Firm, Michael Kaeske, Jr., Kaeske Law Firm & Mona Lisa Wallace, Wallace and Graham, P.A.. Norwood Alderman, Plaintiff, represented by Eric Manchin, Kaeske Law Firm, John S. Hughes, Wallace and Graham, P.A., Lynn Bradshaw, Kaeske Law Firm, Michael Kaeske, Jr., Kaeske Law Firm & Mona Lisa Wallace, Wallace and Graham, P.A.. Dennis Burton, Plaintiff, represented by Eric Manchin, Kaeske Law Firm, John S. Hughes, Wallace and Graham, P.A., Lynn Bradshaw, Kaeske Law Firm, Michael Kaeske, Jr., Kaeske Law Firm & Mona Lisa Wallace, Wallace and Graham, P.A.. Geraldine Burton, Plaintiff, represented by Eric Manchin, Kaeske Law Firm, John S. Hughes, Wallace and Graham, P.A., Lynn Bradshaw, Kaeske Law Firm, Michael Kaeske, Jr., Kaeske Law Firm & Mona Lisa Wallace, Wallace and Graham, P.A.. Willie Burton, Plaintiff, represented by Eric Manchin, Kaeske Law Firm, John S. Hughes, Wallace and Graham, P.A., Lynn Bradshaw, Kaeske Law Firm, Michael Kaeske, Jr., Kaeske Law Firm & Mona Lisa Wallace, Wallace and Graham, P.A.. Ollie Burton, Plaintiff, represented by Eric Manchin, Kaeske Law Firm, John S. Hughes, Wallace and Graham, P.A., Lynn Bradshaw, Kaeske Law Firm, Michael Kaeske, Jr., Kaeske Law Firm & Mona Lisa Wallace, Wallace and Graham, P.A.. Carolyn Davis, Plaintiff, represented by Eric Manchin, Kaeske Law Firm, John S. Hughes, Wallace and Graham, P.A., Lynn Bradshaw, Kaeske Law Firm, Michael Kaeske, Jr., Kaeske Law Firm & Mona Lisa Wallace, Wallace and Graham, P.A.. Sharade Davis, Plaintiff, represented by Eric Manchin, Kaeske Law Firm, John S. Hughes, Wallace and Graham, P.A., Lynn Bradshaw, Kaeske Law Firm, Michael Kaeske, Jr., Kaeske Law Firm & Mona Lisa Wallace, Wallace and Graham, P.A.. Hermetta Judge, Plaintiff, represented by Eric Manchin, Kaeske Law Firm, John S. Hughes, Wallace and Graham, P.A., Lynn Bradshaw, Kaeske Law Firm, Michael Kaeske, Jr., Kaeske Law Firm & Mona Lisa Wallace, Wallace and Graham, P.A.. Thurman McArthur Judge, Plaintiff, represented by Eric Manchin, Kaeske Law Firm, John S. Hughes, Wallace and Graham, P.A., Lynn Bradshaw, Kaeske Law Firm, Michael Kaeske, Jr., Kaeske Law Firm & Mona Lisa Wallace, Wallace and Graham, P.A.. Natasha Judge, Plaintiff, represented by Eric Manchin, Kaeske Law Firm, John S. Hughes, Wallace and Graham, P.A., Lynn Bradshaw, Kaeske Law Firm, Michael Kaeske, Jr., Kaeske Law Firm & Mona Lisa Wallace, Wallace and Graham, P.A.. Maya Judge, Plaintiff, represented by Eric Manchin, Kaeske Law Firm, John S. Hughes, Wallace and Graham, P.A., Lynn Bradshaw, Kaeske Law Firm, Michael Kaeske, Jr., Kaeske Law Firm & Mona Lisa Wallace, Wallace and Graham, P.A.. Myron Judge, Plaintiff, represented by Eric Manchin, Kaeske Law Firm, John S. Hughes, Wallace and Graham, P.A., Lynn Bradshaw, Kaeske Law Firm, Michael Kaeske, Jr., Kaeske Law Firm & Mona Lisa Wallace, Wallace and Graham, P.A.. Isolene Scarborough, Plaintiff, represented by Eric Manchin, Kaeske Law Firm, John S. Hughes, Wallace and Graham, P.A., Lynn Bradshaw, Kaeske Law Firm, Michael Kaeske, Jr., Kaeske Law Firm & Mona Lisa Wallace, Wallace and Graham, P.A.. Council Glaspie, Plaintiff, represented by Eric Manchin, Kaeske Law Firm, John S. Hughes, Wallace and Graham, P.A., Lynn Bradshaw, Kaeske Law Firm, Michael Kaeske, Jr., Kaeske Law Firm & Mona Lisa Wallace, Wallace and Graham, P.A.. Joyce Ann Glaspie, Plaintiff, represented by Eric Manchin, Kaeske Law Firm, John S. Hughes, Wallace and Graham, P.A., Lynn Bradshaw, Kaeske Law Firm, Michael Kaeske, Jr., Kaeske Law Firm & Mona Lisa Wallace, Wallace and Graham, P.A.. Rachel Scarbrough, Plaintiff, represented by Eric Manchin, Kaeske Law Firm, John S. Hughes, Wallace and Graham, P.A., Lynn Bradshaw, Kaeske Law Firm, Michael Kaeske, Jr., Kaeske Law Firm & Mona Lisa Wallace, Wallace and Graham, P.A.. Melissa Glaspie, Plaintiff, represented by Eric Manchin, Kaeske Law Firm, John S. Hughes, Wallace and Graham, P.A., Lynn Bradshaw, Kaeske Law Firm, Michael Kaeske, Jr., Kaeske Law Firm & Mona Lisa Wallace, Wallace and Graham, P.A.. Raquan Scarbrough, Plaintiff, represented by Eric Manchin, Kaeske Law Firm, John S. Hughes, Wallace and Graham, P.A., Lynn Bradshaw, Kaeske Law Firm, Michael Kaeske, Jr., Kaeske Law Firm & Mona Lisa Wallace, Wallace and Graham, P.A.. Deborah Peterson, Plaintiff, represented by Eric Manchin, Kaeske Law Firm, John S. Hughes, Wallace and Graham, P.A., Lynn Bradshaw, Kaeske Law Firm, Michael Kaeske, Jr., Kaeske Law Firm & Mona Lisa Wallace, Wallace and Graham, P.A.. Gregory Peterson, Plaintiff, represented by Eric Manchin, Kaeske Law Firm, John S. Hughes, Wallace and Graham, P.A., Lynn Bradshaw, Kaeske Law Firm, Michael Kaeske, Jr., Kaeske Law Firm & Mona Lisa Wallace, Wallace and Graham, P.A.. Collins Lopez, Plaintiff, represented by Eric Manchin, Kaeske Law Firm, John S. Hughes, Wallace and Graham, P.A., Lynn Bradshaw, Kaeske Law Firm, Michael Kaeske, Jr., Kaeske Law Firm & Mona Lisa Wallace, Wallace and Graham, P.A.. Ernestine Savage, Plaintiff, represented by Eric Manchin, Kaeske Law Firm, John S. Hughes, Wallace and Graham, P.A., Lynn Bradshaw, Kaeske Law Firm, Michael Kaeske, Jr., Kaeske Law Firm & Mona Lisa Wallace, Wallace and Graham, P.A.. Jimmie Savage, Plaintiff, represented by Eric Manchin, Kaeske Law Firm, John S. Hughes, Wallace and Graham, P.A., Lynn Bradshaw, Kaeske Law Firm, Michael Kaeske, Jr., Kaeske Law Firm & Mona Lisa Wallace, Wallace and Graham, P.A.. Dorothy Jackson, Plaintiff, represented by Eric Manchin, Kaeske Law Firm, John S. Hughes, Wallace and Graham, P.A., Lynn Bradshaw, Kaeske Law Firm, Michael Kaeske, Jr., Kaeske Law Firm & Mona Lisa Wallace, Wallace and Graham, P.A.. Nova Williams, Plaintiff, represented by Eric Manchin, Kaeske Law Firm, John S. Hughes, Wallace and Graham, P.A., Lynn Bradshaw, Kaeske Law Firm, Michael Kaeske, Jr., Kaeske Law Firm & Mona Lisa Wallace, Wallace and Graham, P.A.. Mr. Woodell McGowan, Plaintiff, represented by Eric Manchin, Kaeske Law Firm, John S. Hughes, Wallace and Graham, P.A., Lynn Bradshaw, Kaeske Law Firm, Michael Kaeske, Jr., Kaeske Law Firm & Mona Lisa Wallace, Wallace and Graham, P.A.. Cartha Williams, Plaintiff, represented by Eric Manchin, Kaeske Law Firm, John S. Hughes, Wallace and Graham, P.A., Lynn Bradshaw, Kaeske Law Firm, Michael Kaeske, Jr., Kaeske Law Firm & Mona Lisa Wallace, Wallace and Graham, P.A.. Elaine Carlton, Plaintiff, represented by Eric Manchin, Kaeske Law Firm, John S. Hughes, Wallace and Graham, P.A., Lynn Bradshaw, Kaeske Law Firm, Michael Kaeske, Jr., Kaeske Law Firm & Mona Lisa Wallace, Wallace and Graham, P.A.. Anthony Carlton, Plaintiff, represented by Eric Manchin, Kaeske Law Firm, John S. Hughes, Wallace and Graham, P.A., Lynn Bradshaw, Kaeske Law Firm, Michael Kaeske, Jr., Kaeske Law Firm & Mona Lisa Wallace, Wallace and Graham, P.A.. Barbara Gibbs, Plaintiff, represented by Eric Manchin, Kaeske Law Firm, John S. Hughes, Wallace and Graham, P.A., Lynn Bradshaw, Kaeske Law Firm, Michael Kaeske, Jr., Kaeske Law Firm & Mona Lisa Wallace, Wallace and Graham, P.A.. Elvis Williams, Plaintiff, represented by Eric Manchin, Kaeske Law Firm, John S. Hughes, Wallace and Graham, P.A., Lynn Bradshaw, Kaeske Law Firm, Michael Kaeske, Jr., Kaeske Law Firm & Mona Lisa Wallace, Wallace and Graham, P.A.. Vonnie Williams, Plaintiff, represented by Eric Manchin, Kaeske Law Firm, John S. Hughes, Wallace and Graham, P.A., Lynn Bradshaw, Kaeske Law Firm, Michael Kaeske, Jr., Kaeske Law Firm & Mona Lisa Wallace, Wallace and Graham, P.A.. Kenneth Carter, Plaintiff, represented by Eric Manchin, Kaeske Law Firm, John S. Hughes, Wallace and Graham, P.A., Lynn Bradshaw, Kaeske Law Firm, Michael Kaeske, Jr., Kaeske Law Firm & Mona Lisa Wallace, Wallace and Graham, P.A.. LaTonya Carter, Plaintiff, represented by Eric Manchin, Kaeske Law Firm, John S. Hughes, Wallace and Graham, P.A., Lynn Bradshaw, Kaeske Law Firm, Michael Kaeske, Jr., Kaeske Law Firm & Mona Lisa Wallace, Wallace and Graham, P.A.. Linnill Farland, Sr., Plaintiff, represented by Eric Manchin, Kaeske Law Firm, John S. Hughes, Wallace and Graham, P.A., Lynn Bradshaw, Kaeske Law Firm, Michael Kaeske, Jr., Kaeske Law Firm & Mona Lisa Wallace, Wallace and Graham, P.A.. Georgia Farland, Plaintiff, represented by Eric Manchin, Kaeske Law Firm, John S. Hughes, Wallace and Graham, P.A., Lynn Bradshaw, Kaeske Law Firm, Michael Kaeske, Jr., Kaeske Law Firm & Mona Lisa Wallace, Wallace and Graham, P.A.. David Carter, Plaintiff, represented by Eric Manchin, Kaeske Law Firm, John S. Hughes, Wallace and Graham, P.A., Lynn Bradshaw, Kaeske Law Firm, Michael Kaeske, Jr., Kaeske Law Firm & Mona Lisa Wallace, Wallace and Graham, P.A.. Dreama Carter, Plaintiff, represented by Eric Manchin, Kaeske Law Firm, John S. Hughes, Wallace and Graham, P.A., Lynn Bradshaw, Kaeske Law Firm, Michael Kaeske, Jr., Kaeske Law Firm & Mona Lisa Wallace, Wallace and Graham, P.A.. James Davis, Sr., Plaintiff, represented by Eric Manchin, Kaeske Law Firm, John S. Hughes, Wallace and Graham, P.A., Lynn Bradshaw, Kaeske Law Firm, Michael Kaeske, Jr., Kaeske Law Firm & Mona Lisa Wallace, Wallace and Graham, P.A.. Jacqueline Davis, Plaintiff, represented by Eric Manchin, Kaeske Law Firm, John S. Hughes, Wallace and Graham, P.A., Lynn Bradshaw, Kaeske Law Firm, Michael Kaeske, Jr., Kaeske Law Firm & Mona Lisa Wallace, Wallace and Graham, P.A.. James Davis, Jr., Plaintiff, represented by Eric Manchin, Kaeske Law Firm, John S. Hughes, Wallace and Graham, P.A., Lynn Bradshaw, Kaeske Law Firm, Michael Kaeske, Jr., Kaeske Law Firm & Mona Lisa Wallace, Wallace and Graham, P.A.. Robert Carter, Plaintiff, represented by Eric Manchin, Kaeske Law Firm, John S. Hughes, Wallace and Graham, P.A., Lynn Bradshaw, Kaeske Law Firm, Michael Kaeske, Jr., Kaeske Law Firm & Mona Lisa Wallace, Wallace and Graham, P.A.. Sabena Carter, Plaintiff, represented by Eric Manchin, Kaeske Law Firm, John S. Hughes, Wallace and Graham, P.A., Lynn Bradshaw, Kaeske Law Firm, Michael Kaeske, Jr., Kaeske Law Firm & Mona Lisa Wallace, Wallace and Graham, P.A.. Eunice Anderson, Plaintiff, represented by Eric Manchin, Kaeske Law Firm, John S. Hughes, Wallace and Graham, P.A., Lynn Bradshaw, Kaeske Law Firm, Michael Kaeske, Jr., Kaeske Law Firm & Mona Lisa Wallace, Wallace and Graham, P.A.. Talley Saunders, Plaintiff, represented by Eric Manchin, Kaeske Law Firm, John S. Hughes, Wallace and Graham, P.A., Lynn Bradshaw, Kaeske Law Firm, Michael Kaeske, Jr., Kaeske Law Firm & Mona Lisa Wallace, Wallace and Graham, P.A.. Edith Saunders, Plaintiff, represented by Eric Manchin, Kaeske Law Firm, John S. Hughes, Wallace and Graham, P.A., Lynn Bradshaw, Kaeske Law Firm, Michael Kaeske, Jr., Kaeske Law Firm & Mona Lisa Wallace, Wallace and Graham, P.A.. Jerry Boney, Plaintiff, represented by Eric Manchin, Kaeske Law Firm, John S. Hughes, Wallace and Graham, P.A., Lynn Bradshaw, Kaeske Law Firm, Michael Kaeske, Jr., Kaeske Law Firm & Mona Lisa Wallace, Wallace and Graham, P.A.. Annie Hayes, Plaintiff, represented by Eric Manchin, Kaeske Law Firm, John S. Hughes, Wallace and Graham, P.A., Lynn Bradshaw, Kaeske Law Firm, Michael Kaeske, Jr., Kaeske Law Firm & Mona Lisa Wallace, Wallace and Graham, P.A.. Mae Mazyck, Plaintiff, represented by Eric Manchin, Kaeske Law Firm, John S. Hughes, Wallace and Graham, P.A., Lynn Bradshaw, Kaeske Law Firm, Michael Kaeske, Jr., Kaeske Law Firm & Mona Lisa Wallace, Wallace and Graham, P.A.. Nicholas Woodard, Sr., Plaintiff, represented by Eric Manchin, Kaeske Law Firm, John S. Hughes, Wallace and Graham, P.A., Lynn Bradshaw, Kaeske Law Firm, Michael Kaeske, Jr., Kaeske Law Firm & Mona Lisa Wallace, Wallace and Graham, P.A.. Evelyn Woodard, Plaintiff, represented by Eric Manchin, Kaeske Law Firm, John S. Hughes, Wallace and Graham, P.A., Lynn Bradshaw, Kaeske Law Firm, Michael Kaeske, Jr., Kaeske Law Firm & Mona Lisa Wallace, Wallace and Graham, P.A.. Dominique Woodard, Plaintiff, represented by Eric Manchin, Kaeske Law Firm, John S. Hughes, Wallace and Graham, P.A., Lynn Bradshaw, Kaeske Law Firm, Michael Kaeske, Jr., Kaeske Law Firm & Mona Lisa Wallace, Wallace and Graham, P.A.. Shatinah Woodard, Plaintiff, represented by Eric Manchin, Kaeske Law Firm, John S. Hughes, Wallace and Graham, P.A., Lynn Bradshaw, Kaeske Law Firm, Michael Kaeske, Jr., Kaeske Law Firm & Mona Lisa Wallace, Wallace and Graham, P.A.. Tony Farrior, Plaintiff, represented by Eric Manchin, Kaeske Law Firm, John S. Hughes, Wallace and Graham, P.A., Lynn Bradshaw, Kaeske Law Firm, Michael Kaeske, Jr., Kaeske Law Firm & Mona Lisa Wallace, Wallace and Graham, P.A.. Kecia Farrior, Plaintiff, represented by Eric Manchin, Kaeske Law Firm, John S. Hughes, Wallace and Graham, P.A., Lynn Bradshaw, Kaeske Law Firm, Michael Kaeske, Jr., Kaeske Law Firm & Mona Lisa Wallace, Wallace and Graham, P.A.. Annie Harper, Plaintiff, represented by Eric Manchin, Kaeske Law Firm, John S. Hughes, Wallace and Graham, P.A., Lynn Bradshaw, Kaeske Law Firm, Michael Kaeske, Jr., Kaeske Law Firm & Mona Lisa Wallace, Wallace and Graham, P.A.. James Harper, Jr., Plaintiff, represented by Eric Manchin, Kaeske Law Firm, John S. Hughes, Wallace and Graham, P.A., Lynn Bradshaw, Kaeske Law Firm, Michael Kaeske, Jr., Kaeske Law Firm & Mona Lisa Wallace, Wallace and Graham, P.A.. Jediael Leak, Plaintiff, represented by Eric Manchin, Kaeske Law Firm, John S. Hughes, Wallace and Graham, P.A., Lynn Bradshaw, Kaeske Law Firm, Michael Kaeske, Jr., Kaeske Law Firm & Mona Lisa Wallace, Wallace and Graham, P.A.. Janice Pickett, Plaintiff, represented by Eric Manchin, Kaeske Law Firm, John S. Hughes, Wallace and Graham, P.A., Lynn Bradshaw, Kaeske Law Firm, Michael Kaeske, Jr., Kaeske Law Firm & Mona Lisa Wallace, Wallace and Graham, P.A.. Richard Williams, Plaintiff, represented by Eric Manchin, Kaeske Law Firm, John S. Hughes, Wallace and Graham, P.A., Lynn Bradshaw, Kaeske Law Firm, Michael Kaeske, Jr., Kaeske Law Firm & Mona Lisa Wallace, Wallace and Graham, P.A.. Margaret Williams, Plaintiff, represented by Eric Manchin, Kaeske Law Firm, John S. Hughes, Wallace and Graham, P.A., Lynn Bradshaw, Kaeske Law Firm, Michael Kaeske, Jr., Kaeske Law Firm & Mona Lisa Wallace, Wallace and Graham, P.A.. Calvin Melvin, Plaintiff, represented by Eric Manchin, Kaeske Law Firm, John S. Hughes, Wallace and Graham, P.A., Lynn Bradshaw, Kaeske Law Firm, Michael Kaeske, Jr., Kaeske Law Firm & Mona Lisa Wallace, Wallace and Graham, P.A.. Debbie Melvin, Plaintiff, represented by Eric Manchin, Kaeske Law Firm, John S. Hughes, Wallace and Graham, P.A., Lynn Bradshaw, Kaeske Law Firm, Michael Kaeske, Jr., Kaeske Law Firm & Mona Lisa Wallace, Wallace and Graham, P.A.. Celestine Brown Smith, Plaintiff, represented by Eric Manchin, Kaeske Law Firm, John S. Hughes, Wallace and Graham, P.A., Lynn Bradshaw, Kaeske Law Firm, Michael Kaeske, Jr., Kaeske Law Firm & Mona Lisa Wallace, Wallace and Graham, P.A.. Sandra C Bethune, Plaintiff, represented by Eric Manchin, Kaeske Law Firm, John S. Hughes, Wallace and Graham, P.A., Lynn Bradshaw, Kaeske Law Firm, Michael Kaeske, Jr., Kaeske Law Firm & Mona Lisa Wallace, Wallace and Graham, P.A.. Donald David Carr, Plaintiff, represented by Eric Manchin, Kaeske Law Firm, John S. Hughes, Wallace and Graham, P.A., Lynn Bradshaw, Kaeske Law Firm, Michael Kaeske, Jr., Kaeske Law Firm & Mona Lisa Wallace, Wallace and Graham, P.A.. Carolyn B Carr, Plaintiff, represented by Eric Manchin, Kaeske Law Firm, John S. Hughes, Wallace and Graham, P.A., Lynn Bradshaw, Kaeske Law Firm, Michael Kaeske, Jr., Kaeske Law Firm & Mona Lisa Wallace, Wallace and Graham, P.A.. Gregory Carr, Plaintiff, represented by Eric Manchin, Kaeske Law Firm, John S. Hughes, Wallace and Graham, P.A., Lynn Bradshaw, Kaeske Law Firm, Michael Kaeske, Jr., Kaeske Law Firm & Mona Lisa Wallace, Wallace and Graham, P.A.. Robert Bethune, Plaintiff, represented by Eric Manchin, Kaeske Law Firm, John S. Hughes, Wallace and Graham, P.A., Lynn Bradshaw, Kaeske Law Firm, Michael Kaeske, Jr., Kaeske Law Firm & Mona Lisa Wallace, Wallace and Graham, P.A.. Delois Bethune, Plaintiff, represented by Eric Manchin, Kaeske Law Firm, John S. Hughes, Wallace and Graham, P.A., Lynn Bradshaw, Kaeske Law Firm, Michael Kaeske, Jr., Kaeske Law Firm & Mona Lisa Wallace, Wallace and Graham, P.A.. Gemell Bethune, Plaintiff, represented by Eric Manchin, Kaeske Law Firm, John S. Hughes, Wallace and Graham, P.A., Lynn Bradshaw, Kaeske Law Firm, Michael Kaeske, Jr., Kaeske Law Firm & Mona Lisa Wallace, Wallace and Graham, P.A.. Jeffery Lanier, Plaintiff, represented by Eric Manchin, Kaeske Law Firm, John S. Hughes, Wallace and Graham, P.A., Lynn Bradshaw, Kaeske Law Firm, Michael Kaeske, Jr., Kaeske Law Firm & Mona Lisa Wallace, Wallace and Graham, P.A.. Doris Chasten, Plaintiff, represented by Eric Manchin, Kaeske Law Firm, John S. Hughes, Wallace and Graham, P.A., Lynn Bradshaw, Kaeske Law Firm, Michael Kaeske, Jr., Kaeske Law Firm & Mona Lisa Wallace, Wallace and Graham, P.A.. Julaine Bennerman, Plaintiff, represented by Eric Manchin, Kaeske Law Firm, John S. Hughes, Wallace and Graham, P.A., Lynn Bradshaw, Kaeske Law Firm, Michael Kaeske, Jr., Kaeske Law Firm & Mona Lisa Wallace, Wallace and Graham, P.A.. Annjeanette Gillis, Plaintiff, represented by Eric Manchin, Kaeske Law Firm, John S. Hughes, Wallace and Graham, P.A., Lynn Bradshaw, Kaeske Law Firm, Michael Kaeske, Jr., Kaeske Law Firm & Mona Lisa Wallace, Wallace and Graham, P.A.. Daqwan Robinson, Plaintiff, represented by Eric Manchin, Kaeske Law Firm, John S. Hughes, Wallace and Graham, P.A., Lynn Bradshaw, Kaeske Law Firm, Michael Kaeske, Jr., Kaeske Law Firm & Mona Lisa Wallace, Wallace and Graham, P.A.. Woody Gillis, Plaintiff, represented by Eric Manchin, Kaeske Law Firm, John S. Hughes, Wallace and Graham, P.A., Lynn Bradshaw, Kaeske Law Firm, Michael Kaeske, Jr., Kaeske Law Firm & Mona Lisa Wallace, Wallace and Graham, P.A.. Gwendolyn Pickett, Plaintiff, represented by Eric Manchin, Kaeske Law Firm, John S. Hughes, Wallace and Graham, P.A., Lynn Bradshaw, Kaeske Law Firm, Michael Kaeske, Jr., Kaeske Law Firm & Mona Lisa Wallace, Wallace and Graham, P.A.. Allen A Johnson, Plaintiff, represented by Eric Manchin, Kaeske Law Firm, John S. Hughes, Wallace and Graham, P.A., Lynn Bradshaw, Kaeske Law Firm, Michael Kaeske, Jr., Kaeske Law Firm & Mona Lisa Wallace, Wallace and Graham, P.A.. William Murphy, Plaintiff, represented by Eric Manchin, Kaeske Law Firm, John S. Hughes, Wallace and Graham, P.A., Lynn Bradshaw, Kaeske Law Firm, Michael Kaeske, Jr., Kaeske Law Firm & Mona Lisa Wallace, Wallace and Graham, P.A.. Edna Murphy, Plaintiff, represented by Eric Manchin, Kaeske Law Firm, John S. Hughes, Wallace and Graham, P.A., Lynn Bradshaw, Kaeske Law Firm, Michael Kaeske, Jr., Kaeske Law Firm & Mona Lisa Wallace, Wallace and Graham, P.A.. Roberto Murphy, Plaintiff, represented by Eric Manchin, Kaeske Law Firm, John S. Hughes, Wallace and Graham, P.A., Lynn Bradshaw, Kaeske Law Firm, Michael Kaeske, Jr., Kaeske Law Firm & Mona Lisa Wallace, Wallace and Graham, P.A.. Mary Tatum, Plaintiff, represented by Eric Manchin, Kaeske Law Firm, John S. Hughes, Wallace and Graham, P.A., Lynn Bradshaw, Kaeske Law Firm, Michael Kaeske, Jr., Kaeske Law Firm & Mona Lisa Wallace, Wallace and Graham, P.A.. Lottie Fowler, Plaintiff, represented by Eric Manchin, Kaeske Law Firm, John S. Hughes, Wallace and Graham, P.A., Lynn Bradshaw, Kaeske Law Firm, Michael Kaeske, Jr., Kaeske Law Firm & Mona Lisa Wallace, Wallace and Graham, P.A.. Darlene Fowler Maynor, Plaintiff, represented by Eric Manchin, Kaeske Law Firm, John S. Hughes, Wallace and Graham, P.A., Lynn Bradshaw, Kaeske Law Firm, Michael Kaeske, Jr., Kaeske Law Firm & Mona Lisa Wallace, Wallace and Graham, P.A.. Kim Newton, Plaintiff, represented by Eric Manchin, Kaeske Law Firm, John S. Hughes, Wallace and Graham, P.A., Lynn Bradshaw, Kaeske Law Firm, Michael Kaeske, Jr., Kaeske Law Firm & Mona Lisa Wallace, Wallace and Graham, P.A.. Connie Newton, Plaintiff, represented by Eric Manchin, Kaeske Law Firm, John S. Hughes, Wallace and Graham, P.A., Lynn Bradshaw, Kaeske Law Firm, Michael Kaeske, Jr., Kaeske Law Firm & Mona Lisa Wallace, Wallace and Graham, P.A.. Kiron Newton, Plaintiff, represented by Eric Manchin, Kaeske Law Firm, John S. Hughes, Wallace and Graham, P.A., Lynn Bradshaw, Kaeske Law Firm, Michael Kaeske, Jr., Kaeske Law Firm & Mona Lisa Wallace, Wallace and Graham, P.A.. Elsie Herring, Plaintiff, represented by Eric Manchin, Kaeske Law Firm, John S. Hughes, Wallace and Graham, P.A., Lynn Bradshaw, Kaeske Law Firm, Michael Kaeske, Jr., Kaeske Law Firm & Mona Lisa Wallace, Wallace and Graham, P.A.. Robert Pickett, Plaintiff, represented by Eric Manchin, Kaeske Law Firm, John S. Hughes, Wallace and Graham, P.A., Lynn Bradshaw, Kaeske Law Firm, Michael Kaeske, Jr., Kaeske Law Firm & Mona Lisa Wallace, Wallace and Graham, P.A.. Jessie Brinson, Plaintiff, represented by Eric Manchin, Kaeske Law Firm, John S. Hughes, Wallace and Graham, P.A., Lynn Bradshaw, Kaeske Law Firm, Michael Kaeske, Jr., Kaeske Law Firm & Mona Lisa Wallace, Wallace and Graham, P.A.. John Bannerman, Plaintiff, represented by Eric Manchin, Kaeske Law Firm, John S. Hughes, Wallace and Graham, P.A., Lynn Bradshaw, Kaeske Law Firm, Michael Kaeske, Jr., Kaeske Law Firm & Mona Lisa Wallace, Wallace and Graham, P.A.. Clarence Bannerman, Plaintiff, represented by Eric Manchin, Kaeske Law Firm, John S. Hughes, Wallace and Graham, P.A., Lynn Bradshaw, Kaeske Law Firm, Michael Kaeske, Jr., Kaeske Law Firm & Mona Lisa Wallace, Wallace and Graham, P.A.. Violet Branch, Plaintiff, represented by Eric Manchin, Kaeske Law Firm, John S. Hughes, Wallace and Graham, P.A., Lynn Bradshaw, Kaeske Law Firm, Michael Kaeske, Jr., Kaeske Law Firm & Mona Lisa Wallace, Wallace and Graham, P.A.. Olivia Vann Smith, Plaintiff, represented by Eric Manchin, Kaeske Law Firm, John S. Hughes, Wallace and Graham, P.A., Lynn Bradshaw, Kaeske Law Firm, Michael Kaeske, Jr., Kaeske Law Firm & Mona Lisa Wallace, Wallace and Graham, P.A.. Minnie Brinson, Plaintiff, represented by Eric Manchin, Kaeske Law Firm, John S. Hughes, Wallace and Graham, P.A., Lynn Bradshaw, Kaeske Law Firm, Michael Kaeske, Jr., Kaeske Law Firm & Mona Lisa Wallace, Wallace and Graham, P.A.. Gregory Brinson, Plaintiff, represented by Eric Manchin, Kaeske Law Firm, John S. Hughes, Wallace and Graham, P.A., Lynn Bradshaw, Kaeske Law Firm, Michael Kaeske, Jr., Kaeske Law Firm & Mona Lisa Wallace, Wallace and Graham, P.A.. Alisa Brinson, Plaintiff, represented by Eric Manchin, Kaeske Law Firm, John S. Hughes, Wallace and Graham, P.A., Lynn Bradshaw, Kaeske Law Firm, Michael Kaeske, Jr., Kaeske Law Firm & Mona Lisa Wallace, Wallace and Graham, P.A.. Edna Walker, Plaintiff, represented by Eric Manchin, Kaeske Law Firm, John S. Hughes, Wallace and Graham, P.A., Lynn Bradshaw, Kaeske Law Firm, Michael Kaeske, Jr., Kaeske Law Firm & Mona Lisa Wallace, Wallace and Graham, P.A.. Annie Washington, Plaintiff, represented by Eric Manchin, Kaeske Law Firm, John S. Hughes, Wallace and Graham, P.A., Lynn Bradshaw, Kaeske Law Firm, Michael Kaeske, Jr., Kaeske Law Firm & Mona Lisa Wallace, Wallace and Graham, P.A.. Virginia Boone, Plaintiff, represented by Eric Manchin, Kaeske Law Firm, John S. Hughes, Wallace and Graham, P.A., Lynn Bradshaw, Kaeske Law Firm, Michael Kaeske, Jr., Kaeske Law Firm & Mona Lisa Wallace, Wallace and Graham, P.A.. Lillie Waymon, Plaintiff, represented by Eric Manchin, Kaeske Law Firm, John S. Hughes, Wallace and Graham, P.A., Lynn Bradshaw, Kaeske Law Firm, Michael Kaeske, Jr., Kaeske Law Firm & Mona Lisa Wallace, Wallace and Graham, P.A.. Jimmy Waymon, Plaintiff, represented by Eric Manchin, Kaeske Law Firm, John S. Hughes, Wallace and Graham, P.A., Lynn Bradshaw, Kaeske Law Firm, Michael Kaeske, Jr., Kaeske Law Firm & Mona Lisa Wallace, Wallace and Graham, P.A.. Jessie Lisane, Jr., Plaintiff, represented by Eric Manchin, Kaeske Law Firm, John S. Hughes, Wallace and Graham, P.A., Lynn Bradshaw, Kaeske Law Firm, Michael Kaeske, Jr., Kaeske Law Firm & Mona Lisa Wallace, Wallace and Graham, P.A.. Jacqueline McCalop Lisane, Plaintiff, represented by Eric Manchin, Kaeske Law Firm, John S. Hughes, Wallace and Graham, P.A., Lynn Bradshaw, Kaeske Law Firm, Michael Kaeske, Jr., Kaeske Law Firm & Mona Lisa Wallace, Wallace and Graham, P.A.. Carolyn Ann Glasper, Plaintiff, represented by Eric Manchin, Kaeske Law Firm, John S. Hughes, Wallace and Graham, P.A., Lynn Bradshaw, Kaeske Law Firm, Michael Kaeske, Jr., Kaeske Law Firm & Mona Lisa Wallace, Wallace and Graham, P.A.. Andrew James, Plaintiff, represented by Eric Manchin, Kaeske Law Firm, John S. Hughes, Wallace and Graham, P.A., Lynn Bradshaw, Kaeske Law Firm, Michael Kaeske, Jr., Kaeske Law Firm & Mona Lisa Wallace, Wallace and Graham, P.A.. Betty James, Plaintiff, represented by Eric Manchin, Kaeske Law Firm, John S. Hughes, Wallace and Graham, P.A., Lynn Bradshaw, Kaeske Law Firm, Michael Kaeske, Jr., Kaeske Law Firm & Mona Lisa Wallace, Wallace and Graham, P.A.. David McCleary Jarman, Plaintiff, represented by Eric Manchin, Kaeske Law Firm, John S. Hughes, Wallace and Graham, P.A., Lynn Bradshaw, Kaeske Law Firm, Michael Kaeske, Jr., Kaeske Law Firm & Mona Lisa Wallace, Wallace and Graham, P.A.. Wilma Diana Jarman Evans, Plaintiff, represented by Eric Manchin, Kaeske Law Firm, John S. Hughes, Wallace and Graham, P.A., Lynn Bradshaw, Kaeske Law Firm, Michael Kaeske, Jr., Kaeske Law Firm & Mona Lisa Wallace, Wallace and Graham, P.A.. Helen C Dobson, Plaintiff, represented by Eric Manchin, Kaeske Law Firm, John S. Hughes, Wallace and Graham, P.A., Lynn Bradshaw, Kaeske Law Firm, Michael Kaeske, Jr., Kaeske Law Firm & Mona Lisa Wallace, Wallace and Graham, P.A.. James Davies Dobson, Plaintiff, represented by Eric Manchin, Kaeske Law Firm, John S. Hughes, Wallace and Graham, P.A., Lynn Bradshaw, Kaeske Law Firm, Michael Kaeske, Jr., Kaeske Law Firm & Mona Lisa Wallace, Wallace and Graham, P.A.. Rachella Dobson, Plaintiff, represented by Eric Manchin, Kaeske Law Firm, John S. Hughes, Wallace and Graham, P.A., Lynn Bradshaw, Kaeske Law Firm, Michael Kaeske, Jr., Kaeske Law Firm & Mona Lisa Wallace, Wallace and Graham, P.A.. Cassandra Chasten, Plaintiff, represented by Eric Manchin, Kaeske Law Firm, John S. Hughes, Wallace and Graham, P.A., Lynn Bradshaw, Kaeske Law Firm, Michael Kaeske, Jr., Kaeske Law Firm & Mona Lisa Wallace, Wallace and Graham, P.A.. Joan Hall Scarbough, Plaintiff, represented by Eric Manchin, Kaeske Law Firm, John S. Hughes, Wallace and Graham, P.A., Lynn Bradshaw, Kaeske Law Firm, Michael Kaeske, Jr., Kaeske Law Firm & Mona Lisa Wallace, Wallace and Graham, P.A.. Ward Scarbough, Plaintiff, represented by Eric Manchin, Kaeske Law Firm, John S. Hughes, Wallace and Graham, P.A., Lynn Bradshaw, Kaeske Law Firm, Michael Kaeske, Jr., Kaeske Law Firm & Mona Lisa Wallace, Wallace and Graham, P.A.. Lindsay Council Hall, Plaintiff, represented by Eric Manchin, Kaeske Law Firm, John S. Hughes, Wallace and Graham, P.A., Lynn Bradshaw, Kaeske Law Firm, Michael Kaeske, Jr., Kaeske Law Firm & Mona Lisa Wallace, Wallace and Graham, P.A.. Flora Hall, Plaintiff, represented by Eric Manchin, Kaeske Law Firm, John S. Hughes, Wallace and Graham, P.A., Lynn Bradshaw, Kaeske Law Firm, Michael Kaeske, Jr., Kaeske Law Firm & Mona Lisa Wallace, Wallace and Graham, P.A.. Felicia Johnson, Plaintiff, represented by Eric Manchin, Kaeske Law Firm, John S. Hughes, Wallace and Graham, P.A., Lynn Bradshaw, Kaeske Law Firm, Michael Kaeske, Jr., Kaeske Law Firm & Mona Lisa Wallace, Wallace and Graham, P.A.. Latoria Marie Johnson, Plaintiff, represented by Eric Manchin, Kaeske Law Firm, John S. Hughes, Wallace and Graham, P.A., Lynn Bradshaw, Kaeske Law Firm, Michael Kaeske, Jr., Kaeske Law Firm & Mona Lisa Wallace, Wallace and Graham, P.A.. Bruce Hall, Plaintiff, represented by Eric Manchin, Kaeske Law Firm, John S. Hughes, Wallace and Graham, P.A., Lynn Bradshaw, Kaeske Law Firm, Michael Kaeske, Jr., Kaeske Law Firm & Mona Lisa Wallace, Wallace and Graham, P.A.. Fostina Lisane Cooper, Plaintiff, represented by Eric Manchin, Kaeske Law Firm, John S. Hughes, Wallace and Graham, P.A., Lynn Bradshaw, Kaeske Law Firm, Michael Kaeske, Jr., Kaeske Law Firm & Mona Lisa Wallace, Wallace and Graham, P.A.. Evelyn Boney James, Plaintiff, represented by Eric Manchin, Kaeske Law Firm, John S. Hughes, Wallace and Graham, P.A., Lynn Bradshaw, Kaeske Law Firm, Michael Kaeske, Jr., Kaeske Law Firm & Mona Lisa Wallace, Wallace and Graham, P.A.. Barry Henry, Plaintiff, represented by Eric Manchin, Kaeske Law Firm, John S. Hughes, Wallace and Graham, P.A., Lynn Bradshaw, Kaeske Law Firm, Michael Kaeske, Jr., Kaeske Law Firm & Mona Lisa Wallace, Wallace and Graham, P.A.. Maxine Spencer, Plaintiff, represented by Eric Manchin, Kaeske Law Firm, John S. Hughes, Wallace and Graham, P.A., Lynn Bradshaw, Kaeske Law Firm, Michael Kaeske, Jr., Kaeske Law Firm & Mona Lisa Wallace, Wallace and Graham, P.A.. Rita Boney Butler, Plaintiff, represented by Eric Manchin, Kaeske Law Firm, John S. Hughes, Wallace and Graham, P.A., Lynn Bradshaw, Kaeske Law Firm, Michael Kaeske, Jr., Kaeske Law Firm & Mona Lisa Wallace, Wallace and Graham, P.A.. Alma S Rocha, Plaintiff, represented by Eric Manchin, Kaeske Law Firm, John S. Hughes, Wallace and Graham, P.A., Lynn Bradshaw, Kaeske Law Firm, Michael Kaeske, Jr., Kaeske Law Firm & Mona Lisa Wallace, Wallace and Graham, P.A.. Winfred Douglass Chasten, Plaintiff, represented by Eric Manchin, Kaeske Law Firm, John S. Hughes, Wallace and Graham, P.A., Lynn Bradshaw, Kaeske Law Firm, Michael Kaeske, Jr., Kaeske Law Firm & Mona Lisa Wallace, Wallace and Graham, P.A.. Dorival S Rocha, Plaintiff, represented by Eric Manchin, Kaeske Law Firm, John S. Hughes, Wallace and Graham, P.A., Lynn Bradshaw, Kaeske Law Firm, Michael Kaeske, Jr., Kaeske Law Firm & Mona Lisa Wallace, Wallace and Graham, P.A.. Jennifer Herring, Plaintiff, represented by Eric Manchin, Kaeske Law Firm, John S. Hughes, Wallace and Graham, P.A., Lynn Bradshaw, Kaeske Law Firm, Michael Kaeske, Jr., Kaeske Law Firm & Mona Lisa Wallace, Wallace and Graham, P.A.. Mary Lorena Williams, Plaintiff, represented by Eric Manchin, Kaeske Law Firm, John S. Hughes, Wallace and Graham, P.A., Lynn Bradshaw, Kaeske Law Firm, Michael Kaeske, Jr., Kaeske Law Firm & Mona Lisa Wallace, Wallace and Graham, P.A.. Jacqualine Newkirk, Plaintiff, represented by Eric Manchin, Kaeske Law Firm, John S. Hughes, Wallace and Graham, P.A., Lynn Bradshaw, Kaeske Law Firm, Michael Kaeske, Jr., Kaeske Law Firm & Mona Lisa Wallace, Wallace and Graham, P.A.. Lee Ann Williams, Plaintiff, represented by Eric Manchin, Kaeske Law Firm, John S. Hughes, Wallace and Graham, P.A., Lynn Bradshaw, Kaeske Law Firm, Michael Kaeske, Jr., Kaeske Law Firm & Mona Lisa Wallace, Wallace and Graham, P.A.. Antonio Williams, Sr., Plaintiff, represented by Eric Manchin, Kaeske Law Firm, John S. Hughes, Wallace and Graham, P.A., Lynn Bradshaw, Kaeske Law Firm, Michael Kaeske, Jr., Kaeske Law Firm & Mona Lisa Wallace, Wallace and Graham, P.A.. Annette M Williams, Plaintiff, represented by Eric Manchin, Kaeske Law Firm, John S. Hughes, Wallace and Graham, P.A., Lynn Bradshaw, Kaeske Law Firm, Michael Kaeske, Jr., Kaeske Law Firm & Mona Lisa Wallace, Wallace and Graham, P.A.. Willie Kea, Jr., Plaintiff, represented by Eric Manchin, Kaeske Law Firm, John S. Hughes, Wallace and Graham, P.A., Lynn Bradshaw, Kaeske Law Firm, Michael Kaeske, Jr., Kaeske Law Firm & Mona Lisa Wallace, Wallace and Graham, P.A.. Rene Miller, Plaintiff, represented by Eric Manchin, Kaeske Law Firm, John S. Hughes, Wallace and Graham, P.A., Lynn Bradshaw, Kaeske Law Firm, Michael Kaeske, Jr., Kaeske Law Firm & Mona Lisa Wallace, Wallace and Graham, P.A.. Glenda Barton, Plaintiff, represented by Eric Manchin, Kaeske Law Firm, John S. Hughes, Wallace and Graham, P.A., Lynn Bradshaw, Kaeske Law Firm, Michael Kaeske, Jr., Kaeske Law Firm & Mona Lisa Wallace, Wallace and Graham, P.A.. Emma Lou King Collins, Plaintiff, represented by Eric Manchin, Kaeske Law Firm, John S. Hughes, Wallace and Graham, P.A., Lynn Bradshaw, Kaeske Law Firm, Michael Kaeske, Jr., Kaeske Law Firm & Mona Lisa Wallace, Wallace and Graham, P.A.. Adlene Herring, Plaintiff, represented by Eric Manchin, Kaeske Law Firm, John S. Hughes, Wallace and Graham, P.A., Lynn Bradshaw, Kaeske Law Firm, Michael Kaeske, Jr., Kaeske Law Firm & Mona Lisa Wallace, Wallace and Graham, P.A.. Denzel Herring, Plaintiff, represented by Eric Manchin, Kaeske Law Firm, John S. Hughes, Wallace and Graham, P.A., Lynn Bradshaw, Kaeske Law Firm, Michael Kaeske, Jr., Kaeske Law Firm & Mona Lisa Wallace, Wallace and Graham, P.A.. Joe Herring, Plaintiff, represented by Eric Manchin, Kaeske Law Firm, John S. Hughes, Wallace and Graham, P.A., Lynn Bradshaw, Kaeske Law Firm, Michael Kaeske, Jr., Kaeske Law Firm & Mona Lisa Wallace, Wallace and Graham, P.A.. Annie Herring, Plaintiff, represented by Eric Manchin, Kaeske Law Firm, John S. Hughes, Wallace and Graham, P.A., Lynn Bradshaw, Kaeske Law Firm, Michael Kaeske, Jr., Kaeske Law Firm & Mona Lisa Wallace, Wallace and Graham, P.A.. Howard Murphy, Plaintiff, represented by Eric Manchin, Kaeske Law Firm, John S. Hughes, Wallace and Graham, P.A., Lynn Bradshaw, Kaeske Law Firm, Michael Kaeske, Jr., Kaeske Law Firm & Mona Lisa Wallace, Wallace and Graham, P.A.. Joyce Murphy, Plaintiff, represented by Eric Manchin, Kaeske Law Firm, John S. Hughes, Wallace and Graham, P.A., Lynn Bradshaw, Kaeske Law Firm, Michael Kaeske, Jr., Kaeske Law Firm & Mona Lisa Wallace, Wallace and Graham, P.A.. Ned Robinson, Plaintiff, represented by Eric Manchin, Kaeske Law Firm, John S. Hughes, Wallace and Graham, P.A., Lynn Bradshaw, Kaeske Law Firm, Michael Kaeske, Jr., Kaeske Law Firm & Mona Lisa Wallace, Wallace and Graham, P.A.. William Robinson, Plaintiff, represented by Eric Manchin, Kaeske Law Firm, John S. Hughes, Wallace and Graham, P.A., Lynn Bradshaw, Kaeske Law Firm, Michael Kaeske, Jr., Kaeske Law Firm & Mona Lisa Wallace, Wallace and Graham, P.A.. Helen McKoy Blanks, Plaintiff, represented by Eric Manchin, Kaeske Law Firm, John S. Hughes, Wallace and Graham, P.A., Lynn Bradshaw, Kaeske Law Firm, Michael Kaeske, Jr., Kaeske Law Firm & Mona Lisa Wallace, Wallace and Graham, P.A.. Kandace Blanks, Plaintiff, represented by Eric Manchin, Kaeske Law Firm, John S. Hughes, Wallace and Graham, P.A., Lynn Bradshaw, Kaeske Law Firm, Michael Kaeske, Jr., Kaeske Law Firm & Mona Lisa Wallace, Wallace and Graham, P.A.. Master Blanks, Plaintiff, represented by Eric Manchin, Kaeske Law Firm, John S. Hughes, Wallace and Graham, P.A., Lynn Bradshaw, Kaeske Law Firm, Michael Kaeske, Jr., Kaeske Law Firm & Mona Lisa Wallace, Wallace and Graham, P.A.. Nicholas Blanks, Plaintiff, represented by Eric Manchin, Kaeske Law Firm, John S. Hughes, Wallace and Graham, P.A., Lynn Bradshaw, Kaeske Law Firm, Michael Kaeske, Jr., Kaeske Law Firm & Mona Lisa Wallace, Wallace and Graham, P.A.. Andrew Lee Brown, Plaintiff, represented by Eric Manchin, Kaeske Law Firm, John S. Hughes, Wallace and Graham, P.A., Lynn Bradshaw, Kaeske Law Firm, Michael Kaeske, Jr., Kaeske Law Firm & Mona Lisa Wallace, Wallace and Graham, P.A.. Ann Frances Brown, Plaintiff, represented by Eric Manchin, Kaeske Law Firm, John S. Hughes, Wallace and Graham, P.A., Lynn Bradshaw, Kaeske Law Firm, Michael Kaeske, Jr., Kaeske Law Firm & Mona Lisa Wallace, Wallace and Graham, P.A.. Tammaura Marshaye Brown, Plaintiff, represented by Eric Manchin, Kaeske Law Firm, John S. Hughes, Wallace and Graham, P.A., Lynn Bradshaw, Kaeske Law Firm, Michael Kaeske, Jr., Kaeske Law Firm & Mona Lisa Wallace, Wallace and Graham, P.A.. Cyril Harrington, Plaintiff, represented by Eric Manchin, Kaeske Law Firm, John S. Hughes, Wallace and Graham, P.A., Lynn Bradshaw, Kaeske Law Firm, Michael Kaeske, Jr., Kaeske Law Firm & Mona Lisa Wallace, Wallace and Graham, P.A.. Danielle Marie Harrington, Plaintiff, represented by Eric Manchin, Kaeske Law Firm, John S. Hughes, Wallace and Graham, P.A., Lynn Bradshaw, Kaeske Law Firm, Michael Kaeske, Jr., Kaeske Law Firm & Mona Lisa Wallace, Wallace and Graham, P.A.. Katrina Harvey, Plaintiff, represented by Eric Manchin, Kaeske Law Firm, John S. Hughes, Wallace and Graham, P.A., Lynn Bradshaw, Kaeske Law Firm, Michael Kaeske, Jr., Kaeske Law Firm & Mona Lisa Wallace, Wallace and Graham, P.A.. Barbara McKoy Jamison, Plaintiff, represented by Eric Manchin, Kaeske Law Firm, John S. Hughes, Wallace and Graham, P.A., Lynn Bradshaw, Kaeske Law Firm, Michael Kaeske, Jr., Kaeske Law Firm & Mona Lisa Wallace, Wallace and Graham, P.A.. Lawandra Dinah McKoy, Plaintiff, represented by Eric Manchin, Kaeske Law Firm, John S. Hughes, Wallace and Graham, P.A., Lynn Bradshaw, Kaeske Law Firm, Michael Kaeske, Jr., Kaeske Law Firm & Mona Lisa Wallace, Wallace and Graham, P.A.. Marvin Devon McKoy, Plaintiff, represented by Eric Manchin, Kaeske Law Firm, John S. Hughes, Wallace and Graham, P.A., Lynn Bradshaw, Kaeske Law Firm, Michael Kaeske, Jr., Kaeske Law Firm & Mona Lisa Wallace, Wallace and Graham, P.A.. Billie Monroe, Plaintiff, represented by Eric Manchin, Kaeske Law Firm, John S. Hughes, Wallace and Graham, P.A., Lynn Bradshaw, Kaeske Law Firm, Michael Kaeske, Jr., Kaeske Law Firm & Mona Lisa Wallace, Wallace and Graham, P.A.. Cleveland Adolph Monroe, Plaintiff, represented by Eric Manchin, Kaeske Law Firm, John S. Hughes, Wallace and Graham, P.A., Lynn Bradshaw, Kaeske Law Firm, Michael Kaeske, Jr., Kaeske Law Firm & Mona Lisa Wallace, Wallace and Graham, P.A.. Louise Vernell Monroe, Plaintiff, represented by Eric Manchin, Kaeske Law Firm, John S. Hughes, Wallace and Graham, P.A., Lynn Bradshaw, Kaeske Law Firm & Michael Kaeske, Jr., Kaeske Law Firm. Avery Adrayle Willis, Jr., Plaintiff, represented by Eric Manchin, Kaeske Law Firm, John S. Hughes, Wallace and Graham, P.A., Lynn Bradshaw, Kaeske Law Firm, Michael Kaeske, Jr., Kaeske Law Firm & Mona Lisa Wallace, Wallace and Graham, P.A.. Carolyn McKoy Wright, Plaintiff, represented by Eric Manchin, Kaeske Law Firm, John S. Hughes, Wallace and Graham, P.A., Lynn Bradshaw, Kaeske Law Firm, Michael Kaeske, Jr., Kaeske Law Firm & Mona Lisa Wallace, Wallace and Graham, P.A.. John Baker, Plaintiff, represented by Eric Manchin, Kaeske Law Firm, John S. Hughes, Wallace and Graham, P.A., Lynn Bradshaw, Kaeske Law Firm, Michael Kaeske, Jr., Kaeske Law Firm & Mona Lisa Wallace, Wallace and Graham, P.A.. Betty Baker, Plaintiff, represented by Eric Manchin, Kaeske Law Firm, John S. Hughes, Wallace and Graham, P.A., Lynn Bradshaw, Kaeske Law Firm, Michael Kaeske, Jr., Kaeske Law Firm & Mona Lisa Wallace, Wallace and Graham, P.A.. Mackie Baker, Plaintiff, represented by Eric Manchin, Kaeske Law Firm, John S. Hughes, Wallace and Graham, P.A., Lynn Bradshaw, Kaeske Law Firm, Michael Kaeske, Jr., Kaeske Law Firm & Mona Lisa Wallace, Wallace and Graham, P.A.. Raeford Batts, Plaintiff, represented by Eric Manchin, Kaeske Law Firm, John S. Hughes, Wallace and Graham, P.A., Lynn Bradshaw, Kaeske Law Firm, Michael Kaeske, Jr., Kaeske Law Firm & Mona Lisa Wallace, Wallace and Graham, P.A.. Rosemary Batts, Plaintiff, represented by Eric Manchin, Kaeske Law Firm, John S. Hughes, Wallace and Graham, P.A., Lynn Bradshaw, Kaeske Law Firm, Michael Kaeske, Jr., Kaeske Law Firm & Mona Lisa Wallace, Wallace and Graham, P.A.. Detria Batts, Plaintiff, represented by Eric Manchin, Kaeske Law Firm, John S. Hughes, Wallace and Graham, P.A., Lynn Bradshaw, Kaeske Law Firm, Michael Kaeske, Jr., Kaeske Law Firm & Mona Lisa Wallace, Wallace and Graham, P.A.. Ronald Lee Baker, Plaintiff, represented by Eric Manchin, Kaeske Law Firm, John S. Hughes, Wallace and Graham, P.A., Lynn Bradshaw, Kaeske Law Firm, Michael Kaeske, Jr., Kaeske Law Firm & Mona Lisa Wallace, Wallace and Graham, P.A.. Joyce Ann Hardison, Plaintiff, represented by Eric Manchin, Kaeske Law Firm, John S. Hughes, Wallace and Graham, P.A., Lynn Bradshaw, Kaeske Law Firm, Michael Kaeske, Jr., Kaeske Law Firm & Mona Lisa Wallace, Wallace and Graham, P.A.. James Whitley, Jr., Plaintiff, represented by Eric Manchin, Kaeske Law Firm, John S. Hughes, Wallace and Graham, P.A., Lynn Bradshaw, Kaeske Law Firm, Michael Kaeske, Jr., Kaeske Law Firm & Mona Lisa Wallace, Wallace and Graham, P.A.. Minnie Mae Price, Plaintiff, represented by Eric Manchin, Kaeske Law Firm, John S. Hughes, Wallace and Graham, P.A., Lynn Bradshaw, Kaeske Law Firm, Michael Kaeske, Jr., Kaeske Law Firm & Mona Lisa Wallace, Wallace and Graham, P.A.. Lemuel Price, Plaintiff, represented by Eric Manchin, Kaeske Law Firm, John S. Hughes, Wallace and Graham, P.A., Lynn Bradshaw, Kaeske Law Firm, Michael Kaeske, Jr., Kaeske Law Firm & Mona Lisa Wallace, Wallace and Graham, P.A.. Felicia Bannerman, Plaintiff, represented by Eric Manchin, Kaeske Law Firm, John S. Hughes, Wallace and Graham, P.A., Lynn Bradshaw, Kaeske Law Firm, Michael Kaeske, Jr., Kaeske Law Firm & Mona Lisa Wallace, Wallace and Graham, P.A.. Terra Kenan, Plaintiff, represented by Eric Manchin, Kaeske Law Firm, John S. Hughes, Wallace and Graham, P.A., Lynn Bradshaw, Kaeske Law Firm, Michael Kaeske, Jr., Kaeske Law Firm & Mona Lisa Wallace, Wallace and Graham, P.A.. Shirley Temple Kelly, Plaintiff, represented by Eric Manchin, Kaeske Law Firm, John S. Hughes, Wallace and Graham, P.A., Lynn Bradshaw, Kaeske Law Firm, Michael Kaeske, Jr., Kaeske Law Firm & Mona Lisa Wallace, Wallace and Graham, P.A.. Joe Terrano Kelly, Plaintiff, represented by Eric Manchin, Kaeske Law Firm, John S. Hughes, Wallace and Graham, P.A., Lynn Bradshaw, Kaeske Law Firm, Michael Kaeske, Jr., Kaeske Law Firm & Mona Lisa Wallace, Wallace and Graham, P.A.. Alonzo Kelly, Jr., Plaintiff, represented by Eric Manchin, Kaeske Law Firm, John S. Hughes, Wallace and Graham, P.A., Lynn Bradshaw, Kaeske Law Firm, Michael Kaeske, Jr., Kaeske Law Firm & Mona Lisa Wallace, Wallace and Graham, P.A.. Iola Pickett Hall, Plaintiff, represented by Eric Manchin, Kaeske Law Firm, John S. Hughes, Wallace and Graham, P.A., Lynn Bradshaw, Kaeske Law Firm, Michael Kaeske, Jr., Kaeske Law Firm & Mona Lisa Wallace, Wallace and Graham, P.A.. Evangeline Kenan, Plaintiff, represented by Eric Manchin, Kaeske Law Firm, John S. Hughes, Wallace and Graham, P.A., Lynn Bradshaw, Kaeske Law Firm, Michael Kaeske, Jr., Kaeske Law Firm & Mona Lisa Wallace, Wallace and Graham, P.A.. Tony Orlando Hall, Plaintiff, represented by Eric Manchin, Kaeske Law Firm, John S. Hughes, Wallace and Graham, P.A., Lynn Bradshaw, Kaeske Law Firm, Michael Kaeske, Jr., Kaeske Law Firm & Mona Lisa Wallace, Wallace and Graham, P.A.. Eddie Ray Hall, Plaintiff, represented by Eric Manchin, Kaeske Law Firm, John S. Hughes, Wallace and Graham, P.A., Lynn Bradshaw, Kaeske Law Firm, Michael Kaeske, Jr., Kaeske Law Firm & Mona Lisa Wallace, Wallace and Graham, P.A.. Frances Cheryl Hall, Plaintiff, represented by Eric Manchin, Kaeske Law Firm, John S. Hughes, Wallace and Graham, P.A., Lynn Bradshaw, Kaeske Law Firm, Michael Kaeske, Jr., Kaeske Law Firm & Mona Lisa Wallace, Wallace and Graham, P.A.. Freeman Sealey, Plaintiff, represented by Eric Manchin, Kaeske Law Firm, John S. Hughes, Wallace and Graham, P.A., Lynn Bradshaw, Kaeske Law Firm, Michael Kaeske, Jr., Kaeske Law Firm & Mona Lisa Wallace, Wallace and Graham, P.A.. Betty Jean Sloan, Plaintiff, represented by Eric Manchin, Kaeske Law Firm, John S. Hughes, Wallace and Graham, P.A., Lynn Bradshaw, Kaeske Law Firm, Michael Kaeske, Jr., Kaeske Law Firm & Mona Lisa Wallace, Wallace and Graham, P.A.. Jerry Sloan, Plaintiff, represented by Eric Manchin, Kaeske Law Firm, John S. Hughes, Wallace and Graham, P.A., Lynn Bradshaw, Kaeske Law Firm, Michael Kaeske, Jr., Kaeske Law Firm & Mona Lisa Wallace, Wallace and Graham, P.A.. Edward Ingram, Plaintiff, represented by Eric Manchin, Kaeske Law Firm, John S. Hughes, Wallace and Graham, P.A., Lynn Bradshaw, Kaeske Law Firm, Michael Kaeske, Jr., Kaeske Law Firm & Mona Lisa Wallace, Wallace and Graham, P.A.. Russell Pickett, Plaintiff, represented by Eric Manchin, Kaeske Law Firm, John S. Hughes, Wallace and Graham, P.A., Lynn Bradshaw, Kaeske Law Firm, Michael Kaeske, Jr., Kaeske Law Firm & Mona Lisa Wallace, Wallace and Graham, P.A.. Geneva Pickett, Plaintiff, represented by Eric Manchin, Kaeske Law Firm, John S. Hughes, Wallace and Graham, P.A., Lynn Bradshaw, Kaeske Law Firm, Michael Kaeske, Jr., Kaeske Law Firm & Mona Lisa Wallace, Wallace and Graham, P.A.. James Willoughby, Sr., Plaintiff, represented by Eric Manchin, Kaeske Law Firm, John S. Hughes, Wallace and Graham, P.A., Lynn Bradshaw, Kaeske Law Firm, Michael Kaeske, Jr., Kaeske Law Firm & Mona Lisa Wallace, Wallace and Graham, P.A.. Rosie Willoughby, Plaintiff, represented by Eric Manchin, Kaeske Law Firm, John S. Hughes, Wallace and Graham, P.A., Lynn Bradshaw, Kaeske Law Firm, Michael Kaeske, Jr., Kaeske Law Firm & Mona Lisa Wallace, Wallace and Graham, P.A.. Frederick Pickett, Plaintiff, represented by Eric Manchin, Kaeske Law Firm, John S. Hughes, Wallace and Graham, P.A., Lynn Bradshaw, Kaeske Law Firm, Michael Kaeske, Jr., Kaeske Law Firm & Mona Lisa Wallace, Wallace and Graham, P.A.. George Pickett, Plaintiff, represented by Eric Manchin, Kaeske Law Firm, John S. Hughes, Wallace and Graham, P.A., Lynn Bradshaw, Kaeske Law Firm, Michael Kaeske, Jr., Kaeske Law Firm & Mona Lisa Wallace, Wallace and Graham, P.A.. Cheryl Flowers, Plaintiff, represented by Eric Manchin, Kaeske Law Firm, John S. Hughes, Wallace and Graham, P.A., Lynn Bradshaw, Kaeske Law Firm, Michael Kaeske, Jr., Kaeske Law Firm & Mona Lisa Wallace, Wallace and Graham, P.A.. Charles Lee Wade, Plaintiff, represented by Eric Manchin, Kaeske Law Firm, John S. Hughes, Wallace and Graham, P.A., Lynn Bradshaw, Kaeske Law Firm, Michael Kaeske, Jr., Kaeske Law Firm & Mona Lisa Wallace, Wallace and Graham, P.A.. Mary P. Wade, Plaintiff, represented by Eric Manchin, Kaeske Law Firm, John S. Hughes, Wallace and Graham, P.A., Lynn Bradshaw, Kaeske Law Firm, Michael Kaeske, Jr., Kaeske Law Firm & Mona Lisa Wallace, Wallace and Graham, P.A.. Mary W. Jones, Plaintiff, represented by Eric Manchin, Kaeske Law Firm, John S. Hughes, Wallace and Graham, P.A., Lynn Bradshaw, Kaeske Law Firm, Michael Kaeske, Jr., Kaeske Law Firm & Mona Lisa Wallace, Wallace and Graham, P.A.. Patricia Parker Pickett, Plaintiff, represented by Eric Manchin, Kaeske Law Firm, John S. Hughes, Wallace and Graham, P.A., Lynn Bradshaw, Kaeske Law Firm, Michael Kaeske, Jr., Kaeske Law Firm & Mona Lisa Wallace, Wallace and Graham, P.A.. Sarah Ann Pickett, Plaintiff, represented by Eric Manchin, Kaeske Law Firm, John S. Hughes, Wallace and Graham, P.A., Lynn Bradshaw, Kaeske Law Firm, Michael Kaeske, Jr., Kaeske Law Firm & Mona Lisa Wallace, Wallace and Graham, P.A.. Perry Pickett, Plaintiff, represented by Eric Manchin, Kaeske Law Firm, John S. Hughes, Wallace and Graham, P.A., Lynn Bradshaw, Kaeske Law Firm, Michael Kaeske, Jr., Kaeske Law Firm & Mona Lisa Wallace, Wallace and Graham, P.A.. Mekonne Shonte Swann, Plaintiff, represented by Eric Manchin, Kaeske Law Firm, John S. Hughes, Wallace and Graham, P.A., Lynn Bradshaw, Kaeske Law Firm, Michael Kaeske, Jr., Kaeske Law Firm & Mona Lisa Wallace, Wallace and Graham, P.A.. Retha Pickett, Plaintiff, represented by Eric Manchin, Kaeske Law Firm, John S. Hughes, Wallace and Graham, P.A., Lynn Bradshaw, Kaeske Law Firm, Michael Kaeske, Jr., Kaeske Law Firm & Mona Lisa Wallace, Wallace and Graham, P.A.. Marvin Gay Pickett, Plaintiff, represented by Eric Manchin, Kaeske Law Firm, John S. Hughes, Wallace and Graham, P.A., Lynn Bradshaw, Kaeske Law Firm, Michael Kaeske, Jr., Kaeske Law Firm & Mona Lisa Wallace, Wallace and Graham, P.A.. Laura Pickett, Plaintiff, represented by Eric Manchin, Kaeske Law Firm, John S. Hughes, Wallace and Graham, P.A., Lynn Bradshaw, Kaeske Law Firm, Michael Kaeske, Jr., Kaeske Law Firm & Mona Lisa Wallace, Wallace and Graham, P.A.. Walter Pickett, Plaintiff, represented by Eric Manchin, Kaeske Law Firm, John S. Hughes, Wallace and Graham, P.A., Lynn Bradshaw, Kaeske Law Firm, Michael Kaeske, Jr., Kaeske Law Firm & Mona Lisa Wallace, Wallace and Graham, P.A.. James Arlanda Pickett, Plaintiff, represented by Eric Manchin, Kaeske Law Firm, John S. Hughes, Wallace and Graham, P.A., Lynn Bradshaw, Kaeske Law Firm, Michael Kaeske, Jr., Kaeske Law Firm & Mona Lisa Wallace, Wallace and Graham, P.A.. Sara Lou Batts, Plaintiff, represented by Eric Manchin, Kaeske Law Firm, John S. Hughes, Wallace and Graham, P.A., Lynn Bradshaw, Kaeske Law Firm, Michael Kaeske, Jr., Kaeske Law Firm & Mona Lisa Wallace, Wallace and Graham, P.A.. Corey Batts, Plaintiff, represented by Eric Manchin, Kaeske Law Firm, John S. Hughes, Wallace and Graham, P.A., Lynn Bradshaw, Kaeske Law Firm, Michael Kaeske, Jr., Kaeske Law Firm & Mona Lisa Wallace, Wallace and Graham, P.A.. Raymond Batts, Plaintiff, represented by Eric Manchin, Kaeske Law Firm, John S. Hughes, Wallace and Graham, P.A., Lynn Bradshaw, Kaeske Law Firm, Michael Kaeske, Jr., Kaeske Law Firm & Mona Lisa Wallace, Wallace and Graham, P.A.. Joseph Dean Pickett, Plaintiff, represented by Eric Manchin, Kaeske Law Firm, John S. Hughes, Wallace and Graham, P.A., Lynn Bradshaw, Kaeske Law Firm, Michael Kaeske, Jr., Kaeske Law Firm & Mona Lisa Wallace, Wallace and Graham, P.A.. Lannie Faye Pickett, Plaintiff, represented by Eric Manchin, Kaeske Law Firm, John S. Hughes, Wallace and Graham, P.A., Lynn Bradshaw, Kaeske Law Firm, Michael Kaeske, Jr., Kaeske Law Firm & Mona Lisa Wallace, Wallace and Graham, P.A.. Rhoda Campbell, Plaintiff, represented by Eric Manchin, Kaeske Law Firm, John S. Hughes, Wallace and Graham, P.A., Lynn Bradshaw, Kaeske Law Firm, Michael Kaeske, Jr., Kaeske Law Firm & Mona Lisa Wallace, Wallace and Graham, P.A.. Alma Sharpless, Plaintiff, represented by Eric Manchin, Kaeske Law Firm, John S. Hughes, Wallace and Graham, P.A., Lynn Bradshaw, Kaeske Law Firm, Michael Kaeske, Jr., Kaeske Law Firm & Mona Lisa Wallace, Wallace and Graham, P.A.. Mildred Kenan, Plaintiff, represented by Eric Manchin, Kaeske Law Firm, John S. Hughes, Wallace and Graham, P.A., Lynn Bradshaw, Kaeske Law Firm, Michael Kaeske, Jr., Kaeske Law Firm & Mona Lisa Wallace, Wallace and Graham, P.A.. Harry Edward Kenan, Plaintiff, represented by Eric Manchin, Kaeske Law Firm, John S. Hughes, Wallace and Graham, P.A., Lynn Bradshaw, Kaeske Law Firm, Michael Kaeske, Jr., Kaeske Law Firm & Mona Lisa Wallace, Wallace and Graham, P.A.. Alex Sharpless, Plaintiff, represented by Eric Manchin, Kaeske Law Firm, John S. Hughes, Wallace and Graham, P.A., Lynn Bradshaw, Kaeske Law Firm, Michael Kaeske, Jr., Kaeske Law Firm & Mona Lisa Wallace, Wallace and Graham, P.A.. Panzyta Kenan, Plaintiff, represented by Eric Manchin, Kaeske Law Firm, John S. Hughes, Wallace and Graham, P.A., Lynn Bradshaw, Kaeske Law Firm, Michael Kaeske, Jr., Kaeske Law Firm & Mona Lisa Wallace, Wallace and Graham, P.A.. Edythe Kenan Brown, Plaintiff, represented by Eric Manchin, Kaeske Law Firm, John S. Hughes, Wallace and Graham, P.A., Lynn Bradshaw, Kaeske Law Firm, Michael Kaeske, Jr., Kaeske Law Firm & Mona Lisa Wallace, Wallace and Graham, P.A.. Evett Pickett, Plaintiff, represented by Eric Manchin, Kaeske Law Firm, John S. Hughes, Wallace and Graham, P.A., Lynn Bradshaw, Kaeske Law Firm, Michael Kaeske, Jr., Kaeske Law Firm & Mona Lisa Wallace, Wallace and Graham, P.A.. Pauline Hill, Plaintiff, represented by Eric Manchin, Kaeske Law Firm, John S. Hughes, Wallace and Graham, P.A., Lynn Bradshaw, Kaeske Law Firm, Michael Kaeske, Jr., Kaeske Law Firm & Mona Lisa Wallace, Wallace and Graham, P.A.. Adele Whitehead Jones, Plaintiff, represented by Eric Manchin, Kaeske Law Firm, John S. Hughes, Wallace and Graham, P.A., Lynn Bradshaw, Kaeske Law Firm, Michael Kaeske, Jr., Kaeske Law Firm & Mona Lisa Wallace, Wallace and Graham, P.A.. Fostina Jones, Plaintiff, represented by Eric Manchin, Kaeske Law Firm, John S. Hughes, Wallace and Graham, P.A., Lynn Bradshaw, Kaeske Law Firm, Michael Kaeske, Jr., Kaeske Law Firm & Mona Lisa Wallace, Wallace and Graham, P.A.. brian Pickett, Plaintiff, represented by Eric Manchin, Kaeske Law Firm, John S. Hughes, Wallace and Graham, P.A., Lynn Bradshaw, Kaeske Law Firm, Michael Kaeske, Jr., Kaeske Law Firm & Mona Lisa Wallace, Wallace and Graham, P.A.. Deborah Goodman Totten, Plaintiff, represented by Eric Manchin, Kaeske Law Firm, John S. Hughes, Wallace and Graham, P.A., Lynn Bradshaw, Kaeske Law Firm, Michael Kaeske, Jr., Kaeske Law Firm & Mona Lisa Wallace, Wallace and Graham, P.A.. Laverne Fullwood, Plaintiff, represented by Eric Manchin, Kaeske Law Firm, John S. Hughes, Wallace and Graham, P.A., Lynn Bradshaw, Kaeske Law Firm, Michael Kaeske, Jr., Kaeske Law Firm & Mona Lisa Wallace, Wallace and Graham, P.A.. James Anthony Miller, Plaintiff, represented by Eric Manchin, Kaeske Law Firm, John S. Hughes, Wallace and Graham, P.A., Lynn Bradshaw, Kaeske Law Firm, Michael Kaeske, Jr., Kaeske Law Firm & Mona Lisa Wallace, Wallace and Graham, P.A.. Oshonia Sherryl Miller, Plaintiff, represented by Eric Manchin, Kaeske Law Firm, John S. Hughes, Wallace and Graham, P.A., Lynn Bradshaw, Kaeske Law Firm, Michael Kaeske, Jr., Kaeske Law Firm & Mona Lisa Wallace, Wallace and Graham, P.A.. George Alton Martin, Plaintiff, represented by Eric Manchin, Kaeske Law Firm, John S. Hughes, Wallace and Graham, P.A., Lynn Bradshaw, Kaeske Law Firm, Michael Kaeske, Jr., Kaeske Law Firm & Mona Lisa Wallace, Wallace and Graham, P.A.. Sondra Marshell Martin, Plaintiff, represented by Eric Manchin, Kaeske Law Firm, John S. Hughes, Wallace and Graham, P.A., Lynn Bradshaw, Kaeske Law Firm, Michael Kaeske, Jr., Kaeske Law Firm & Mona Lisa Wallace, Wallace and Graham, P.A.. James Henry Rose, Plaintiff, represented by Eric Manchin, Kaeske Law Firm, John S. Hughes, Wallace and Graham, P.A., Lynn Bradshaw, Kaeske Law Firm, Michael Kaeske, Jr., Kaeske Law Firm & Mona Lisa Wallace, Wallace and Graham, P.A.. Queenie Elizabeth Rose, Plaintiff, represented by Eric Manchin, Kaeske Law Firm, John S. Hughes, Wallace and Graham, P.A., Lynn Bradshaw, Kaeske Law Firm, Michael Kaeske, Jr., Kaeske Law Firm & Mona Lisa Wallace, Wallace and Graham, P.A.. Martha Joy Miller, Plaintiff, represented by Eric Manchin, Kaeske Law Firm, John S. Hughes, Wallace and Graham, P.A., Lynn Bradshaw, Kaeske Law Firm, Michael Kaeske, Jr., Kaeske Law Firm & Mona Lisa Wallace, Wallace and Graham, P.A.. John Dee Faison, Plaintiff, represented by Eric Manchin, Kaeske Law Firm, John S. Hughes, Wallace and Graham, P.A., Lynn Bradshaw, Kaeske Law Firm, Michael Kaeske, Jr., Kaeske Law Firm & Mona Lisa Wallace, Wallace and Graham, P.A.. Bernita Faison, Plaintiff, represented by Eric Manchin, Kaeske Law Firm, John S. Hughes, Wallace and Graham, P.A., Lynn Bradshaw, Kaeske Law Firm, Michael Kaeske, Jr., Kaeske Law Firm & Mona Lisa Wallace, Wallace and Graham, P.A.. Brenda Atkinson, Plaintiff, represented by Eric Manchin, Kaeske Law Firm, John S. Hughes, Wallace and Graham, P.A., Lynn Bradshaw, Kaeske Law Firm, Michael Kaeske, Jr., Kaeske Law Firm & Mona Lisa Wallace, Wallace and Graham, P.A.. James Atkinson, Plaintiff, represented by Eric Manchin, Kaeske Law Firm, John S. Hughes, Wallace and Graham, P.A., Lynn Bradshaw, Kaeske Law Firm, Michael Kaeske, Jr., Kaeske Law Firm & Mona Lisa Wallace, Wallace and Graham, P.A.. Anna Morrisey, Plaintiff, represented by Eric Manchin, Kaeske Law Firm, John S. Hughes, Wallace and Graham, P.A., Lynn Bradshaw, Kaeske Law Firm, Michael Kaeske, Jr., Kaeske Law Firm & Mona Lisa Wallace, Wallace and Graham, P.A.. Salisa Best, Plaintiff, represented by Eric Manchin, Kaeske Law Firm, John S. Hughes, Wallace and Graham, P.A., Lynn Bradshaw, Kaeske Law Firm, Michael Kaeske, Jr., Kaeske Law Firm & Mona Lisa Wallace, Wallace and Graham, P.A.. Katie Morrisey Brunson, Plaintiff, represented by Eric Manchin, Kaeske Law Firm, John S. Hughes, Wallace and Graham, P.A., Lynn Bradshaw, Kaeske Law Firm, Michael Kaeske, Jr., Kaeske Law Firm & Mona Lisa Wallace, Wallace and Graham, P.A.. Robert Carr, Plaintiff, represented by Eric Manchin, Kaeske Law Firm, John S. Hughes, Wallace and Graham, P.A., Lynn Bradshaw, Kaeske Law Firm, Michael Kaeske, Jr., Kaeske Law Firm & Mona Lisa Wallace, Wallace and Graham, P.A.. Linda Evans, Plaintiff, represented by Eric Manchin, Kaeske Law Firm, John S. Hughes, Wallace and Graham, P.A., Lynn Bradshaw, Kaeske Law Firm, Michael Kaeske, Jr., Kaeske Law Firm & Mona Lisa Wallace, Wallace and Graham, P.A.. Glenn Faison, Plaintiff, represented by Eric Manchin, Kaeske Law Firm, John S. Hughes, Wallace and Graham, P.A., Lynn Bradshaw, Kaeske Law Firm, Michael Kaeske, Jr., Kaeske Law Firm & Mona Lisa Wallace, Wallace and Graham, P.A.. Viola Herring, Plaintiff, represented by Eric Manchin, Kaeske Law Firm, John S. Hughes, Wallace and Graham, P.A., Lynn Bradshaw, Kaeske Law Firm, Michael Kaeske, Jr., Kaeske Law Firm & Mona Lisa Wallace, Wallace and Graham, P.A.. Elaine Faison Hunt, Plaintiff, represented by Eric Manchin, Kaeske Law Firm, John S. Hughes, Wallace and Graham, P.A., Lynn Bradshaw, Kaeske Law Firm, Michael Kaeske, Jr., Kaeske Law Firm & Mona Lisa Wallace, Wallace and Graham, P.A.. Bobby King, Plaintiff, represented by Eric Manchin, Kaeske Law Firm, John S. Hughes, Wallace and Graham, P.A., Lynn Bradshaw, Kaeske Law Firm, Michael Kaeske, Jr., Kaeske Law Firm & Mona Lisa Wallace, Wallace and Graham, P.A.. Joanne King, Plaintiff, represented by Eric Manchin, Kaeske Law Firm, John S. Hughes, Wallace and Graham, P.A., Lynn Bradshaw, Kaeske Law Firm, Michael Kaeske, Jr., Kaeske Law Firm & Mona Lisa Wallace, Wallace and Graham, P.A.. Carolyn Mathis, Plaintiff, represented by Eric Manchin, Kaeske Law Firm, John S. Hughes, Wallace and Graham, P.A., Lynn Bradshaw, Kaeske Law Firm, Michael Kaeske, Jr., Kaeske Law Firm & Mona Lisa Wallace, Wallace and Graham, P.A.. Dorothy Mathis, Plaintiff, represented by Eric Manchin, Kaeske Law Firm, John S. Hughes, Wallace and Graham, P.A., Lynn Bradshaw, Kaeske Law Firm, Michael Kaeske, Jr., Kaeske Law Firm & Mona Lisa Wallace, Wallace and Graham, P.A.. Douglas Mathis, Plaintiff, represented by Eric Manchin, Kaeske Law Firm, John S. Hughes, Wallace and Graham, P.A., Lynn Bradshaw, Kaeske Law Firm, Michael Kaeske, Jr., Kaeske Law Firm & Mona Lisa Wallace, Wallace and Graham, P.A.. Thelma Mathis, Plaintiff, represented by Eric Manchin, Kaeske Law Firm, John S. Hughes, Wallace and Graham, P.A., Lynn Bradshaw, Kaeske Law Firm, Michael Kaeske, Jr., Kaeske Law Firm & Mona Lisa Wallace, Wallace and Graham, P.A.. William Mathis, Plaintiff, represented by Eric Manchin, Kaeske Law Firm, John S. Hughes, Wallace and Graham, P.A., Lynn Bradshaw, Kaeske Law Firm, Michael Kaeske, Jr., Kaeske Law Firm & Mona Lisa Wallace, Wallace and Graham, P.A.. Jerry McClarin, Sr., Plaintiff, represented by Eric Manchin, Kaeske Law Firm, John S. Hughes, Wallace and Graham, P.A., Lynn Bradshaw, Kaeske Law Firm, Michael Kaeske, Jr., Kaeske Law Firm & Mona Lisa Wallace, Wallace and Graham, P.A.. Trumilla McClarin, Plaintiff, represented by Eric Manchin, Kaeske Law Firm, John S. Hughes, Wallace and Graham, P.A., Lynn Bradshaw, Kaeske Law Firm, Michael Kaeske, Jr., Kaeske Law Firm & Mona Lisa Wallace, Wallace and Graham, P.A.. Richard Blow, Plaintiff, represented by Eric Manchin, Kaeske Law Firm, John S. Hughes, Wallace and Graham, P.A., Lynn Bradshaw, Kaeske Law Firm, Michael Kaeske, Jr., Kaeske Law Firm & Mona Lisa Wallace, Wallace and Graham, P.A.. Elverett Hall, Plaintiff, represented by Eric Manchin, Kaeske Law Firm, John S. Hughes, Wallace and Graham, P.A., Lynn Bradshaw, Kaeske Law Firm, Michael Kaeske, Jr., Kaeske Law Firm & Mona Lisa Wallace, Wallace and Graham, P.A.. Aaron Wesley Hall, Plaintiff, represented by Eric Manchin, Kaeske Law Firm, John S. Hughes, Wallace and Graham, P.A., Lynn Bradshaw, Kaeske Law Firm, Michael Kaeske, Jr., Kaeske Law Firm & Mona Lisa Wallace, Wallace and Graham, P.A.. Shirlynn Blow, Plaintiff, represented by Eric Manchin, Kaeske Law Firm, John S. Hughes, Wallace and Graham, P.A., Lynn Bradshaw, Kaeske Law Firm, Michael Kaeske, Jr., Kaeske Law Firm & Mona Lisa Wallace, Wallace and Graham, P.A.. Artis Hall, Plaintiff, represented by Eric Manchin, Kaeske Law Firm, John S. Hughes, Wallace and Graham, P.A., Lynn Bradshaw, Kaeske Law Firm, Michael Kaeske, Jr., Kaeske Law Firm & Mona Lisa Wallace, Wallace and Graham, P.A.. Scotty Hall, Plaintiff, represented by Eric Manchin, Kaeske Law Firm, John S. Hughes, Wallace and Graham, P.A., Lynn Bradshaw, Kaeske Law Firm, Michael Kaeske, Jr., Kaeske Law Firm & Mona Lisa Wallace, Wallace and Graham, P.A.. Jannett H. Bush, Plaintiff, represented by Eric Manchin, Kaeske Law Firm, John S. Hughes, Wallace and Graham, P.A., Lynn Bradshaw, Kaeske Law Firm, Michael Kaeske, Jr., Kaeske Law Firm & Mona Lisa Wallace, Wallace and Graham, P.A.. Ethel Lee Hall, Plaintiff, represented by Eric Manchin, Kaeske Law Firm, John S. Hughes, Wallace and Graham, P.A., Lynn Bradshaw, Kaeske Law Firm, Michael Kaeske, Jr., Kaeske Law Firm & Mona Lisa Wallace, Wallace and Graham, P.A.. James Dully Hall, Plaintiff, represented by Eric Manchin, Kaeske Law Firm, John S. Hughes, Wallace and Graham, P.A., Lynn Bradshaw, Kaeske Law Firm, Michael Kaeske, Jr., Kaeske Law Firm & Mona Lisa Wallace, Wallace and Graham, P.A.. Pamela Hall, Plaintiff, represented by Eric Manchin, Kaeske Law Firm, John S. Hughes, Wallace and Graham, P.A., Lynn Bradshaw, Kaeske Law Firm, Michael Kaeske, Jr., Kaeske Law Firm & Mona Lisa Wallace, Wallace and Graham, P.A.. Ray C. Hall, Plaintiff, represented by Eric Manchin, Kaeske Law Firm, John S. Hughes, Wallace and Graham, P.A., Lynn Bradshaw, Kaeske Law Firm, Michael Kaeske, Jr., Kaeske Law Firm & Mona Lisa Wallace, Wallace and Graham, P.A.. Wilma Hall, Plaintiff, represented by Eric Manchin, Kaeske Law Firm, John S. Hughes, Wallace and Graham, P.A., Lynn Bradshaw, Kaeske Law Firm, Michael Kaeske, Jr., Kaeske Law Firm & Mona Lisa Wallace, Wallace and Graham, P.A.. Gregory Collins Hall, Plaintiff, represented by Eric Manchin, Kaeske Law Firm, John S. Hughes, Wallace and Graham, P.A., Lynn Bradshaw, Kaeske Law Firm, Michael Kaeske, Jr., Kaeske Law Firm & Mona Lisa Wallace, Wallace and Graham, P.A.. Emmett Hall, Plaintiff, represented by Eric Manchin, Kaeske Law Firm, John S. Hughes, Wallace and Graham, P.A., Lynn Bradshaw, Kaeske Law Firm, Michael Kaeske, Jr., Kaeske Law Firm & Mona Lisa Wallace, Wallace and Graham, P.A.. Carolyn Hall, Plaintiff, represented by Eric Manchin, Kaeske Law Firm, John S. Hughes, Wallace and Graham, P.A., Lynn Bradshaw, Kaeske Law Firm, Michael Kaeske, Jr., Kaeske Law Firm & Mona Lisa Wallace, Wallace and Graham, P.A.. Clara Miller, Plaintiff, represented by Eric Manchin, Kaeske Law Firm, John S. Hughes, Wallace and Graham, P.A., Lynn Bradshaw, Kaeske Law Firm, Michael Kaeske, Jr., Kaeske Law Firm & Mona Lisa Wallace, Wallace and Graham, P.A.. Herbert Miller, Plaintiff, represented by Eric Manchin, Kaeske Law Firm, John S. Hughes, Wallace and Graham, P.A., Lynn Bradshaw, Kaeske Law Firm, Michael Kaeske, Jr., Kaeske Law Firm & Mona Lisa Wallace, Wallace and Graham, P.A.. James D. Bowen, Jr., Plaintiff, represented by Eric Manchin, Kaeske Law Firm, John S. Hughes, Wallace and Graham, P.A., Lynn Bradshaw, Kaeske Law Firm, Michael Kaeske, Jr., Kaeske Law Firm & Mona Lisa Wallace, Wallace and Graham, P.A.. Dwayne Bowen, Plaintiff, represented by Eric Manchin, Kaeske Law Firm, John S. Hughes, Wallace and Graham, P.A., Lynn Bradshaw, Kaeske Law Firm, Michael Kaeske, Jr., Kaeske Law Firm & Mona Lisa Wallace, Wallace and Graham, P.A.. James Alfred Henry, Jr., Plaintiff, represented by Eric Manchin, Kaeske Law Firm, John S. Hughes, Wallace and Graham, P.A., Lynn Bradshaw, Kaeske Law Firm, Michael Kaeske, Jr., Kaeske Law Firm & Mona Lisa Wallace, Wallace and Graham, P.A.. James Alfred Henry, Plaintiff, represented by Eric Manchin, Kaeske Law Firm, John S. Hughes, Wallace and Graham, P.A., Lynn Bradshaw, Kaeske Law Firm, Michael Kaeske, Jr., Kaeske Law Firm & Mona Lisa Wallace, Wallace and Graham, P.A.. Shanita L. Henry, Plaintiff, represented by Eric Manchin, Kaeske Law Firm, John S. Hughes, Wallace and Graham, P.A., Lynn Bradshaw, Kaeske Law Firm, Michael Kaeske, Jr., Kaeske Law Firm & Mona Lisa Wallace, Wallace and Graham, P.A.. Charles Herring, Plaintiff, represented by Eric Manchin, Kaeske Law Firm, John S. Hughes, Wallace and Graham, P.A., Lynn Bradshaw, Kaeske Law Firm, Michael Kaeske, Jr., Kaeske Law Firm & Mona Lisa Wallace, Wallace and Graham, P.A.. Joyce Roberts Herring, Plaintiff, represented by Eric Manchin, Kaeske Law Firm, John S. Hughes, Wallace and Graham, P.A., Lynn Bradshaw, Kaeske Law Firm, Michael Kaeske, Jr., Kaeske Law Firm & Mona Lisa Wallace, Wallace and Graham, P.A.. Lou Frances Herring, Plaintiff, represented by Eric Manchin, Kaeske Law Firm, John S. Hughes, Wallace and Graham, P.A., Lynn Bradshaw, Kaeske Law Firm, Michael Kaeske, Jr., Kaeske Law Firm & Mona Lisa Wallace, Wallace and Graham, P.A.. Geraldine Humphrey, Plaintiff, represented by Eric Manchin, Kaeske Law Firm, John S. Hughes, Wallace and Graham, P.A., Lynn Bradshaw, Kaeske Law Firm, Michael Kaeske, Jr., Kaeske Law Firm & Mona Lisa Wallace, Wallace and Graham, P.A.. Gorden Humphrey, Plaintiff, represented by Eric Manchin, Kaeske Law Firm, John S. Hughes, Wallace and Graham, P.A., Lynn Bradshaw, Kaeske Law Firm, Michael Kaeske, Jr., Kaeske Law Firm & Mona Lisa Wallace, Wallace and Graham, P.A.. Joyce Herring Roberts, Plaintiff, represented by Eric Manchin, Kaeske Law Firm, John S. Hughes, Wallace and Graham, P.A., Lynn Bradshaw, Kaeske Law Firm, Michael Kaeske, Jr., Kaeske Law Firm & Mona Lisa Wallace, Wallace and Graham, P.A.. Tony Bennett, Plaintiff, represented by Eric Manchin, Kaeske Law Firm, John S. Hughes, Wallace and Graham, P.A., Lynn Bradshaw, Kaeske Law Firm, Michael Kaeske, Jr., Kaeske Law Firm & Mona Lisa Wallace, Wallace and Graham, P.A.. George Ester Fennell, Plaintiff, represented by Eric Manchin, Kaeske Law Firm, John S. Hughes, Wallace and Graham, P.A., Lynn Bradshaw, Kaeske Law Firm, Michael Kaeske, Jr., Kaeske Law Firm & Mona Lisa Wallace, Wallace and Graham, P.A.. Jerry Fennell, Sr., Plaintiff, represented by Eric Manchin, Kaeske Law Firm, John S. Hughes, Wallace and Graham, P.A., Lynn Bradshaw, Kaeske Law Firm, Michael Kaeske, Jr., Kaeske Law Firm, Mona Lisa Wallace, Wallace and Graham, P.A., Eric Manchin, Kaeske Law Firm, John S. Hughes, Wallace and Graham, P.A., Lynn Bradshaw, Kaeske Law Firm, Michael Kaeske, Jr., Kaeske Law Firm & Mona Lisa Wallace, Wallace and Graham, P.A.. Linda Girley, Plaintiff, represented by Eric Manchin, Kaeske Law Firm, John S. Hughes, Wallace and Graham, P.A., Lynn Bradshaw, Kaeske Law Firm, Michael Kaeske, Jr., Kaeske Law Firm & Mona Lisa Wallace, Wallace and Graham, P.A.. Percy Girley, Plaintiff, represented by Eric Manchin, Kaeske Law Firm, John S. Hughes, Wallace and Graham, P.A., Lynn Bradshaw, Kaeske Law Firm, Michael Kaeske, Jr., Kaeske Law Firm & Mona Lisa Wallace, Wallace and Graham, P.A.. Harry Murphy, Plaintiff, represented by Eric Manchin, Kaeske Law Firm, John S. Hughes, Wallace and Graham, P.A., Lynn Bradshaw, Kaeske Law Firm, Michael Kaeske, Jr., Kaeske Law Firm & Mona Lisa Wallace, Wallace and Graham, P.A.. Sheila Murphy, Plaintiff, represented by Eric Manchin, Kaeske Law Firm, John S. Hughes, Wallace and Graham, P.A., Lynn Bradshaw, Kaeske Law Firm, Michael Kaeske, Jr., Kaeske Law Firm & Mona Lisa Wallace, Wallace and Graham, P.A.. Darien Jerome Murphy, Sr., Plaintiff, represented by Eric Manchin, Kaeske Law Firm, John S. Hughes, Wallace and Graham, P.A., Lynn Bradshaw, Kaeske Law Firm, Michael Kaeske, Jr., Kaeske Law Firm & Mona Lisa Wallace, Wallace and Graham, P.A.. Oliver Murphy, Plaintiff, represented by Eric Manchin, Kaeske Law Firm, John S. Hughes, Wallace and Graham, P.A., Lynn Bradshaw, Kaeske Law Firm, Michael Kaeske, Jr., Kaeske Law Firm & Mona Lisa Wallace, Wallace and Graham, P.A.. Patricia Melvin Pratt, Plaintiff, represented by Eric Manchin, Kaeske Law Firm, John S. Hughes, Wallace and Graham, P.A., Lynn Bradshaw, Kaeske Law Firm, Michael Kaeske, Jr., Kaeske Law Firm & Mona Lisa Wallace, Wallace and Graham, P.A.. Harry Lee Smith, Plaintiff, represented by Eric Manchin, Kaeske Law Firm, John S. Hughes, Wallace and Graham, P.A., Lynn Bradshaw, Kaeske Law Firm, Michael Kaeske, Jr., Kaeske Law Firm & Mona Lisa Wallace, Wallace and Graham, P.A.. Precious L. Smith, Plaintiff, represented by Eric Manchin, Kaeske Law Firm, John S. Hughes, Wallace and Graham, P.A., Lynn Bradshaw, Kaeske Law Firm, Michael Kaeske, Jr., Kaeske Law Firm & Mona Lisa Wallace, Wallace and Graham, P.A.. Rosa Smith, Plaintiff, represented by Eric Manchin, Kaeske Law Firm, John S. Hughes, Wallace and Graham, P.A., Lynn Bradshaw, Kaeske Law Firm, Michael Kaeske, Jr., Kaeske Law Firm & Mona Lisa Wallace, Wallace and Graham, P.A.. Mary E. Underwood, Plaintiff, represented by Eric Manchin, Kaeske Law Firm, John S. Hughes, Wallace and Graham, P.A., Lynn Bradshaw, Kaeske Law Firm, Michael Kaeske, Jr., Kaeske Law Firm & Mona Lisa Wallace, Wallace and Graham, P.A.. Betty Williams, Plaintiff, represented by Eric Manchin, Kaeske Law Firm, John S. Hughes, Wallace and Graham, P.A., Lynn Bradshaw, Kaeske Law Firm, Michael Kaeske, Jr., Kaeske Law Firm & Mona Lisa Wallace, Wallace and Graham, P.A.. Herman Steven Williams, Plaintiff, represented by Eric Manchin, Kaeske Law Firm, John S. Hughes, Wallace and Graham, P.A., Lynn Bradshaw, Kaeske Law Firm, Michael Kaeske, Jr., Kaeske Law Firm & Mona Lisa Wallace, Wallace and Graham, P.A.. Terry Terrelle Williams, Plaintiff, represented by Eric Manchin, Kaeske Law Firm, John S. Hughes, Wallace and Graham, P.A., Lynn Bradshaw, Kaeske Law Firm, Michael Kaeske, Jr., Kaeske Law Firm & Mona Lisa Wallace, Wallace and Graham, P.A.. Willie Thomas Williams, Plaintiff, represented by Eric Manchin, Kaeske Law Firm, John S. Hughes, Wallace and Graham, P.A., Lynn Bradshaw, Kaeske Law Firm, Michael Kaeske, Jr., Kaeske Law Firm & Mona Lisa Wallace, Wallace and Graham, P.A.. Daisy J. Fennell, Plaintiff, represented by Eric Manchin, Kaeske Law Firm, John S. Hughes, Wallace and Graham, P.A., Lynn Bradshaw, Kaeske Law Firm, Michael Kaeske, Jr., Kaeske Law Firm & Mona Lisa Wallace, Wallace and Graham, P.A.. Daisy Williams, Plaintiff, represented by Eric Manchin, Kaeske Law Firm, John S. Hughes, Wallace and Graham, P.A., Lynn Bradshaw, Kaeske Law Firm, Michael Kaeske, Jr., Kaeske Law Firm & Mona Lisa Wallace, Wallace and Graham, P.A.. George F. Williams, Plaintiff, represented by Eric Manchin, Kaeske Law Firm, John S. Hughes, Wallace and Graham, P.A., Lynn Bradshaw, Kaeske Law Firm, Michael Kaeske, Jr., Kaeske Law Firm & Mona Lisa Wallace, Wallace and Graham, P.A.. Shirley Williams, Plaintiff, represented by Eric Manchin, Kaeske Law Firm, John S. Hughes, Wallace and Graham, P.A., Lynn Bradshaw, Kaeske Law Firm, Michael Kaeske, Jr., Kaeske Law Firm & Mona Lisa Wallace, Wallace and Graham, P.A.. Ben Artis, Plaintiff, represented by Eric Manchin, Kaeske Law Firm, John S. Hughes, Wallace and Graham, P.A., Lynn Bradshaw, Kaeske Law Firm, Michael Kaeske, Jr., Kaeske Law Firm & Mona Lisa Wallace, Wallace and Graham, P.A.. Diane Artis, Plaintiff, represented by Eric Manchin, Kaeske Law Firm, John S. Hughes, Wallace and Graham, P.A., Lynn Bradshaw, Kaeske Law Firm, Michael Kaeske, Jr., Kaeske Law Firm & Mona Lisa Wallace, Wallace and Graham, P.A.. Lucy Sidberry, Plaintiff, represented by Eric Manchin, Kaeske Law Firm, John S. Hughes, Wallace and Graham, P.A., Lynn Bradshaw, Kaeske Law Firm, Michael Kaeske, Jr., Kaeske Law Firm & Mona Lisa Wallace, Wallace and Graham, P.A.. Edna Allison, Plaintiff, represented by Eric Manchin, Kaeske Law Firm, John S. Hughes, Wallace and Graham, P.A., Lynn Bradshaw, Kaeske Law Firm, Michael Kaeske, Jr., Kaeske Law Firm & Mona Lisa Wallace, Wallace and Graham, P.A.. Jimmy Carr, Plaintiff, represented by Eric Manchin, Kaeske Law Firm, John S. Hughes, Wallace and Graham, P.A., Lynn Bradshaw, Kaeske Law Firm, Michael Kaeske, Jr., Kaeske Law Firm & Mona Lisa Wallace, Wallace and Graham, P.A.. Gertie Jacobs, Plaintiff, represented by Eric Manchin, Kaeske Law Firm, John S. Hughes, Wallace and Graham, P.A., Lynn Bradshaw, Kaeske Law Firm, Michael Kaeske, Jr., Kaeske Law Firm & Mona Lisa Wallace, Wallace and Graham, P.A.. James Jacobs, Plaintiff, represented by Eric Manchin, Kaeske Law Firm, John S. Hughes, Wallace and Graham, P.A., Lynn Bradshaw, Kaeske Law Firm, Michael Kaeske, Jr., Kaeske Law Firm & Mona Lisa Wallace, Wallace and Graham, P.A.. Leola Jacobs, Plaintiff, represented by Eric Manchin, Kaeske Law Firm, John S. Hughes, Wallace and Graham, P.A., Lynn Bradshaw, Kaeske Law Firm, Michael Kaeske, Jr., Kaeske Law Firm & Mona Lisa Wallace, Wallace and Graham, P.A.. Joyce Messick, Plaintiff, represented by Eric Manchin, Kaeske Law Firm, John S. Hughes, Wallace and Graham, P.A., Lynn Bradshaw, Kaeske Law Firm, Michael Kaeske, Jr., Kaeske Law Firm & Mona Lisa Wallace, Wallace and Graham, P.A.. Willie Messick, Plaintiff, represented by Eric Manchin, Kaeske Law Firm, John S. Hughes, Wallace and Graham, P.A., Lynn Bradshaw, Kaeske Law Firm, Michael Kaeske, Jr., Kaeske Law Firm & Mona Lisa Wallace, Wallace and Graham, P.A.. Eddie Nicholson, Plaintiff, represented by Eric Manchin, Kaeske Law Firm, John S. Hughes, Wallace and Graham, P.A., Lynn Bradshaw, Kaeske Law Firm, Michael Kaeske, Jr., Kaeske Law Firm & Mona Lisa Wallace, Wallace and Graham, P.A.. Lenora Nicholson, Plaintiff, represented by Eric Manchin, Kaeske Law Firm, John S. Hughes, Wallace and Graham, P.A., Lynn Bradshaw, Kaeske Law Firm, Michael Kaeske, Jr., Kaeske Law Firm & Mona Lisa Wallace, Wallace and Graham, P.A.. John Taylor, Plaintiff, represented by Eric Manchin, Kaeske Law Firm, John S. Hughes, Wallace and Graham, P.A., Lynn Bradshaw, Kaeske Law Firm, Michael Kaeske, Jr., Kaeske Law Firm & Mona Lisa Wallace, Wallace and Graham, P.A.. Phyllis Wright, Plaintiff, represented by Eric Manchin, Kaeske Law Firm, John S. Hughes, Wallace and Graham, P.A., Lynn Bradshaw, Kaeske Law Firm, Michael Kaeske, Jr., Kaeske Law Firm & Mona Lisa Wallace, Wallace and Graham, P.A.. James Holmes, Plaintiff, represented by Eric Manchin, Kaeske Law Firm, John S. Hughes, Wallace and Graham, P.A., Lynn Bradshaw, Kaeske Law Firm, Michael Kaeske, Jr., Kaeske Law Firm & Mona Lisa Wallace, Wallace and Graham, P.A.. Lenora Holmes, Plaintiff, represented by Eric Manchin, Kaeske Law Firm, John S. Hughes, Wallace and Graham, P.A., Lynn Bradshaw, Kaeske Law Firm, Michael Kaeske, Jr., Kaeske Law Firm & Mona Lisa Wallace, Wallace and Graham, P.A.. Estate of Ida Cromartie, Plaintiff, represented by Eric Manchin, Kaeske Law Firm, John S. Hughes, Wallace and Graham, P.A., Lynn Bradshaw, Kaeske Law Firm, Michael Kaeske, Jr., Kaeske Law Firm & Mona Lisa Wallace, Wallace and Graham, P.A.. Jennifer Marlena Cromartie, Plaintiff, represented by Eric Manchin, Kaeske Law Firm, John S. Hughes, Wallace and Graham, P.A., Lynn Bradshaw, Kaeske Law Firm, Michael Kaeske, Jr., Kaeske Law Firm & Mona Lisa Wallace, Wallace and Graham, P.A.. Sheena Cromartie, Plaintiff, represented by Eric Manchin, Kaeske Law Firm, John S. Hughes, Wallace and Graham, P.A., Lynn Bradshaw, Kaeske Law Firm, Michael Kaeske, Jr., Kaeske Law Firm & Mona Lisa Wallace, Wallace and Graham, P.A.. Tracy Shameka Cromartie, Plaintiff, represented by Eric Manchin, Kaeske Law Firm, John S. Hughes, Wallace and Graham, P.A., Lynn Bradshaw, Kaeske Law Firm, Michael Kaeske, Jr., Kaeske Law Firm & Mona Lisa Wallace, Wallace and Graham, P.A.. Patrick H. Cromartie, Jr., Plaintiff, represented by Eric Manchin, Kaeske Law Firm, John S. Hughes, Wallace and Graham, P.A., Lynn Bradshaw, Kaeske Law Firm, Michael Kaeske, Jr., Kaeske Law Firm & Mona Lisa Wallace, Wallace and Graham, P.A.. Darlene Jones, Plaintiff, represented by Eric Manchin, Kaeske Law Firm, John S. Hughes, Wallace and Graham, P.A., Lynn Bradshaw, Kaeske Law Firm, Michael Kaeske, Jr., Kaeske Law Firm & Mona Lisa Wallace, Wallace and Graham, P.A.. Bobby Monroe, Plaintiff, represented by Eric Manchin, Kaeske Law Firm, John S. Hughes, Wallace and Graham, P.A., Lynn Bradshaw, Kaeske Law Firm, Michael Kaeske, Jr., Kaeske Law Firm & Mona Lisa Wallace, Wallace and Graham, P.A.. Rita Monroe, Plaintiff, represented by Eric Manchin, Kaeske Law Firm, John S. Hughes, Wallace and Graham, P.A., Lynn Bradshaw, Kaeske Law Firm, Michael Kaeske, Jr., Kaeske Law Firm & Mona Lisa Wallace, Wallace and Graham, P.A.. Samuel Devon Monroe, Plaintiff, represented by Eric Manchin, Kaeske Law Firm, John S. Hughes, Wallace and Graham, P.A., Lynn Bradshaw, Kaeske Law Firm, Michael Kaeske, Jr., Kaeske Law Firm & Mona Lisa Wallace, Wallace and Graham, P.A.. Bobby Farron Monroe, Jr., Plaintiff, represented by Eric Manchin, Kaeske Law Firm, John S. Hughes, Wallace and Graham, P.A., Lynn Bradshaw, Kaeske Law Firm, Michael Kaeske, Jr., Kaeske Law Firm & Mona Lisa Wallace, Wallace and Graham, P.A.. Annie L. Monroe, Plaintiff, represented by Eric Manchin, Kaeske Law Firm, John S. Hughes, Wallace and Graham, P.A., Lynn Bradshaw, Kaeske Law Firm, Michael Kaeske, Jr., Kaeske Law Firm & Mona Lisa Wallace, Wallace and Graham, P.A.. Charles Monroe, Plaintiff, represented by Eric Manchin, Kaeske Law Firm, John S. Hughes, Wallace and Graham, P.A., Lynn Bradshaw, Kaeske Law Firm, Michael Kaeske, Jr., Kaeske Law Firm & Mona Lisa Wallace, Wallace and Graham, P.A.. Deborah Monroe, Plaintiff, represented by Eric Manchin, Kaeske Law Firm, John S. Hughes, Wallace and Graham, P.A., Lynn Bradshaw, Kaeske Law Firm, Michael Kaeske, Jr., Kaeske Law Firm & Mona Lisa Wallace, Wallace and Graham, P.A.. Edward Monroe, Plaintiff, represented by Eric Manchin, Kaeske Law Firm, John S. Hughes, Wallace and Graham, P.A., Lynn Bradshaw, Kaeske Law Firm, Michael Kaeske, Jr., Kaeske Law Firm & Mona Lisa Wallace, Wallace and Graham, P.A.. Jarmar Tremaine Monroe, Plaintiff, represented by Eric Manchin, Kaeske Law Firm, John S. Hughes, Wallace and Graham, P.A., Lynn Bradshaw, Kaeske Law Firm, Michael Kaeske, Jr., Kaeske Law Firm & Mona Lisa Wallace, Wallace and Graham, P.A.. Thurmon Monroe, Sr., Plaintiff, represented by Eric Manchin, Kaeske Law Firm, John S. Hughes, Wallace and Graham, P.A., Lynn Bradshaw, Kaeske Law Firm, Michael Kaeske, Jr., Kaeske Law Firm & Mona Lisa Wallace, Wallace and Graham, P.A.. Richard Laverne Brown, Plaintiff, represented by Eric Manchin, Kaeske Law Firm, John S. Hughes, Wallace and Graham, P.A., Lynn Bradshaw, Kaeske Law Firm, Michael Kaeske, Jr., Kaeske Law Firm & Mona Lisa Wallace, Wallace and Graham, P.A.. Jacqueline G. Hill, Plaintiff, represented by Eric Manchin, Kaeske Law Firm, John S. Hughes, Wallace and Graham, P.A., Lynn Bradshaw, Kaeske Law Firm, Michael Kaeske, Jr., Kaeske Law Firm & Mona Lisa Wallace, Wallace and Graham, P.A.. Patricia Montgomery, Plaintiff, represented by Eric Manchin, Kaeske Law Firm, John S. Hughes, Wallace and Graham, P.A., Lynn Bradshaw, Kaeske Law Firm, Michael Kaeske, Jr., Kaeske Law Firm & Mona Lisa Wallace, Wallace and Graham, P.A.. James Montgomery, Sr., Plaintiff, represented by Eric Manchin, Kaeske Law Firm, John S. Hughes, Wallace and Graham, P.A., Lynn Bradshaw, Kaeske Law Firm, Michael Kaeske, Jr., Kaeske Law Firm & Mona Lisa Wallace, Wallace and Graham, P.A.. Casandra Monroe Murchison, Plaintiff, represented by Eric Manchin, Kaeske Law Firm, John S. Hughes, Wallace and Graham, P.A., Lynn Bradshaw, Kaeske Law Firm, Michael Kaeske, Jr., Kaeske Law Firm & Mona Lisa Wallace, Wallace and Graham, P.A.. Nyiesha Kierra Murchison, Plaintiff, represented by Eric Manchin, Kaeske Law Firm, John S. Hughes, Wallace and Graham, P.A., Lynn Bradshaw, Kaeske Law Firm, Michael Kaeske, Jr., Kaeske Law Firm & Mona Lisa Wallace, Wallace and Graham, P.A.. Willie James Murchison, Plaintiff, represented by Eric Manchin, Kaeske Law Firm, John S. Hughes, Wallace and Graham, P.A., Lynn Bradshaw, Kaeske Law Firm, Michael Kaeske, Jr., Kaeske Law Firm & Mona Lisa Wallace, Wallace and Graham, P.A.. Belveria Ann Webb, Plaintiff, represented by Eric Manchin, Kaeske Law Firm, John S. Hughes, Wallace and Graham, P.A., Lynn Bradshaw, Kaeske Law Firm, Michael Kaeske, Jr., Kaeske Law Firm & Mona Lisa Wallace, Wallace and Graham, P.A.. Delphine Murray Williams, Plaintiff, represented by Eric Manchin, Kaeske Law Firm, John S. Hughes, Wallace and Graham, P.A., Lynn Bradshaw, Kaeske Law Firm, Michael Kaeske, Jr., Kaeske Law Firm & Mona Lisa Wallace, Wallace and Graham, P.A.. Ivan Danyell Williams, Plaintiff, represented by Eric Manchin, Kaeske Law Firm, John S. Hughes, Wallace and Graham, P.A., Lynn Bradshaw, Kaeske Law Firm, Michael Kaeske, Jr., Kaeske Law Firm & Mona Lisa Wallace, Wallace and Graham, P.A.. April Santrice Murray, Plaintiff, represented by Eric Manchin, Kaeske Law Firm, John S. Hughes, Wallace and Graham, P.A., Lynn Bradshaw, Kaeske Law Firm, Michael Kaeske, Jr., Kaeske Law Firm & Mona Lisa Wallace, Wallace and Graham, P.A.. David Earl Murray, Plaintiff, represented by Eric Manchin, Kaeske Law Firm, John S. Hughes, Wallace and Graham, P.A., Lynn Bradshaw, Kaeske Law Firm, Michael Kaeske, Jr., Kaeske Law Firm & Mona Lisa Wallace, Wallace and Graham, P.A.. Ervin M. Murray, Plaintiff, represented by Eric Manchin, Kaeske Law Firm, John S. Hughes, Wallace and Graham, P.A., Lynn Bradshaw, Kaeske Law Firm, Michael Kaeske, Jr., Kaeske Law Firm & Mona Lisa Wallace, Wallace and Graham, P.A.. Linda Williams, Plaintiff, represented by Eric Manchin, Kaeske Law Firm, John S. Hughes, Wallace and Graham, P.A., Lynn Bradshaw, Kaeske Law Firm, Michael Kaeske, Jr., Kaeske Law Firm & Mona Lisa Wallace, Wallace and Graham, P.A.. Bobby James Wyckoff, Plaintiff, represented by Eric Manchin, Kaeske Law Firm, John S. Hughes, Wallace and Graham, P.A., Lynn Bradshaw, Kaeske Law Firm, Michael Kaeske, Jr., Kaeske Law Firm & Mona Lisa Wallace, Wallace and Graham, P.A.. Thelma Jeanette Wyckoff, Plaintiff, represented by Eric Manchin, Kaeske Law Firm, John S. Hughes, Wallace and Graham, P.A., Lynn Bradshaw, Kaeske Law Firm, Michael Kaeske, Jr., Kaeske Law Firm & Mona Lisa Wallace, Wallace and Graham, P.A.. Sharon E. Kirk, Plaintiff, represented by Eric Manchin, Kaeske Law Firm, John S. Hughes, Wallace and Graham, P.A., Lynn Bradshaw, Kaeske Law Firm, Michael Kaeske, Jr., Kaeske Law Firm & Mona Lisa Wallace, Wallace and Graham, P.A.. Deborah J. McGee, Plaintiff, represented by Eric Manchin, Kaeske Law Firm, John S. Hughes, Wallace and Graham, P.A., Lynn Bradshaw, Kaeske Law Firm, Michael Kaeske, Jr., Kaeske Law Firm & Mona Lisa Wallace, Wallace and Graham, P.A.. Lowinelyn McGee, Plaintiff, represented by Eric Manchin, Kaeske Law Firm, John S. Hughes, Wallace and Graham, P.A., Lynn Bradshaw, Kaeske Law Firm, Michael Kaeske, Jr., Kaeske Law Firm & Mona Lisa Wallace, Wallace and Graham, P.A.. Brenda Lee Murray, Plaintiff, represented by Eric Manchin, Kaeske Law Firm, John S. Hughes, Wallace and Graham, P.A., Lynn Bradshaw, Kaeske Law Firm, Michael Kaeske, Jr., Kaeske Law Firm & Mona Lisa Wallace, Wallace and Graham, P.A.. Wilbery Gary Murray, Plaintiff, represented by Eric Manchin, Kaeske Law Firm, John S. Hughes, Wallace and Graham, P.A., Lynn Bradshaw, Kaeske Law Firm, Michael Kaeske, Jr., Kaeske Law Firm & Mona Lisa Wallace, Wallace and Graham, P.A.. Daniel Williams, Plaintiff, represented by Eric Manchin, Kaeske Law Firm, John S. Hughes, Wallace and Graham, P.A., Lynn Bradshaw, Kaeske Law Firm, Michael Kaeske, Jr., Kaeske Law Firm & Mona Lisa Wallace, Wallace and Graham, P.A.. Lular Francis Williams, Plaintiff, represented by Eric Manchin, Kaeske Law Firm, John S. Hughes, Wallace and Graham, P.A., Lynn Bradshaw, Kaeske Law Firm, Michael Kaeske, Jr., Kaeske Law Firm & Mona Lisa Wallace, Wallace and Graham, P.A.. Tonga Boney, Plaintiff, represented by Eric Manchin, Kaeske Law Firm, John S. Hughes, Wallace and Graham, P.A., Lynn Bradshaw, Kaeske Law Firm, Michael Kaeske, Jr., Kaeske Law Firm & Mona Lisa Wallace, Wallace and Graham, P.A.. Annie Carr, Plaintiff, represented by Eric Manchin, Kaeske Law Firm, John S. Hughes, Wallace and Graham, P.A., Lynn Bradshaw, Kaeske Law Firm, Michael Kaeske, Jr., Kaeske Law Firm & Mona Lisa Wallace, Wallace and Graham, P.A.. Dwight Carr, Plaintiff, represented by Eric Manchin, Kaeske Law Firm, John S. Hughes, Wallace and Graham, P.A., Lynn Bradshaw, Kaeske Law Firm, Michael Kaeske, Jr., Kaeske Law Firm & Mona Lisa Wallace, Wallace and Graham, P.A.. Kimberly Carr, Plaintiff, represented by Eric Manchin, Kaeske Law Firm, John S. Hughes, Wallace and Graham, P.A., Lynn Bradshaw, Kaeske Law Firm, Michael Kaeske, Jr., Kaeske Law Firm & Mona Lisa Wallace, Wallace and Graham, P.A.. Wilbert Carr, Plaintiff, represented by Eric Manchin, Kaeske Law Firm, John S. Hughes, Wallace and Graham, P.A., Lynn Bradshaw, Kaeske Law Firm, Michael Kaeske, Jr., Kaeske Law Firm & Mona Lisa Wallace, Wallace and Graham, P.A.. Dwight Delane Dixon, Plaintiff, represented by Eric Manchin, Kaeske Law Firm, John S. Hughes, Wallace and Graham, P.A., Lynn Bradshaw, Kaeske Law Firm, Michael Kaeske, Jr., Kaeske Law Firm & Mona Lisa Wallace, Wallace and Graham, P.A.. Wanda Carlton Dixon, Plaintiff, represented by Eric Manchin, Kaeske Law Firm, John S. Hughes, Wallace and Graham, P.A., Lynn Bradshaw, Kaeske Law Firm, Michael Kaeske, Jr., Kaeske Law Firm & Mona Lisa Wallace, Wallace and Graham, P.A.. Peggy Ardean Fennell, Plaintiff, represented by Eric Manchin, Kaeske Law Firm, John S. Hughes, Wallace and Graham, P.A., Lynn Bradshaw, Kaeske Law Firm, Michael Kaeske, Jr., Kaeske Law Firm & Mona Lisa Wallace, Wallace and Graham, P.A.. Tiara Monet Fennell, Plaintiff, represented by Eric Manchin, Kaeske Law Firm, John S. Hughes, Wallace and Graham, P.A., Lynn Bradshaw, Kaeske Law Firm, Michael Kaeske, Jr., Kaeske Law Firm & Mona Lisa Wallace, Wallace and Graham, P.A.. Rosalind Lee, Plaintiff, represented by Eric Manchin, Kaeske Law Firm, John S. Hughes, Wallace and Graham, P.A., Lynn Bradshaw, Kaeske Law Firm, Michael Kaeske, Jr., Kaeske Law Firm & Mona Lisa Wallace, Wallace and Graham, P.A.. Marilyn Matthews, Plaintiff, represented by Eric Manchin, Kaeske Law Firm, John S. Hughes, Wallace and Graham, P.A., Lynn Bradshaw, Kaeske Law Firm, Michael Kaeske, Jr., Kaeske Law Firm & Mona Lisa Wallace, Wallace and Graham, P.A.. Ronald Matthews, Plaintiff, represented by Eric Manchin, Kaeske Law Firm, John S. Hughes, Wallace and Graham, P.A., Lynn Bradshaw, Kaeske Law Firm, Michael Kaeske, Jr., Kaeske Law Firm & Mona Lisa Wallace, Wallace and Graham, P.A.. Jonathan Matthews, Jr., Plaintiff, represented by Eric Manchin, Kaeske Law Firm, John S. Hughes, Wallace and Graham, P.A., Lynn Bradshaw, Kaeske Law Firm, Michael Kaeske, Jr., Kaeske Law Firm & Mona Lisa Wallace, Wallace and Graham, P.A.. Annie Rawls, Plaintiff, represented by Eric Manchin, Kaeske Law Firm, John S. Hughes, Wallace and Graham, P.A., Lynn Bradshaw, Kaeske Law Firm, Michael Kaeske, Jr., Kaeske Law Firm & Mona Lisa Wallace, Wallace and Graham, P.A.. Cynthia Loretta Dixon Hall, Plaintiff, represented by Eric Manchin, Kaeske Law Firm, John S. Hughes, Wallace and Graham, P.A., Lynn Bradshaw, Kaeske Law Firm, Michael Kaeske, Jr., Kaeske Law Firm & Mona Lisa Wallace, Wallace and Graham, P.A.. Loretta Byrd, Plaintiff, represented by John S. Hughes, Wallace and Graham, P.A. & Mona Lisa Wallace, Wallace and Graham, P.A.. Daniel I. Miller, Plaintiff, represented by Eric Manchin, Kaeske Law Firm, John S. Hughes, Wallace and Graham, P.A., Lynn Bradshaw, Kaeske Law Firm, Michael Kaeske, Jr., Kaeske Law Firm & Mona Lisa Wallace, Wallace and Graham, P.A.. Murphy-Brown, LLC, Defendant, represented by Eugene E. Mathews, McGuireWoods, LLP, Mark E. Anderson, McGuireWoods LLP, Tennille J. Checkovich, McGuireWoods, LLP, Christopher E. Trible, McGuire Woods LLP, Darin K. Waylett, McGuire Woods LLP & Jakarra J. Jones, McGuire Woods LLP. Jones Jr., Robert B., United States Magistrate Judge ORDER *1 This matter is before the court on Plaintiffs' Motion to Compel Discovery of Documents and Electronically Stored Information [DE-114] and Motion to Compel the Production of Smithfield Foods, Inc. Documents Under Defendant's Control [DE-117], Defendant, Murphy-Brown LLC (“Defendant” or “Murphy-Brown”) filed responses in opposition to the motions. [DE-125,-131]. For the reasons that follow, the motions are denied. I. BACKGROUND This litigation is comprised of 26 cases filed in this court alleging claims for nuisance, negligence, and punitive damages stemming from hog farming operations in eastern North Carolina. See, e.g., Anderson v. Murphy-Brown, LLC, No. 7:14-CV-00183-BR, Second Am. Compl. [DE-34], After engaging in preliminary discovery with respect to certain threshold issues, see May 21, 2015 Interim Case Management Order [DE-26], the parties selected the following five cases on which to proceed with more detailed discovery: Anderson v. Murphy-Brown LLC, No. 7:14-CV-00183-BR; Artis v. Murphy-Brown LLC, No. 7:14-CV-00237-BR; Gillis v. Murphy-Brown LLC, No. 7:14-CV-00185-BR; McGowan v. Murphy-Brown LLC, No. 7:14-CV-00182-BR; and McKiver v. Murphy-Brown LLC, No. 7:14-CV-00180-BR (collectively, the “Discovery Pool Cases”). [DE-96-1]. Discovery in the Discovery Pool Cases is underway, with fact discovery to conclude on October 31, 2016, expert discovery to take place thereafter and conclude by February 10, 2017, and dispositive motions to be filed by March 31, 2017. See Apr. 11, 2016 Interim Scheduling Order [DE-96-1]; May 19, 2016 Interim Scheduling Order [DE-111], II. DISCUSSION A. Motion to Compel Discovery of Documents and Electronically Stored Information [DE-114] Plaintiffs served a First Request for Production of Documents (“First RFPs”) in the Discovery Pool Cases on April 29, 2016 and a Second Request for Production of Documents (“Second RFPs”) and First Set of Interrogatories on May 3. Pls.' Br. [DE-115] at 2; Def.'s Opp'n [DE-125] at 2. On May 9, Defendant's counsel emailed Plaintiffs' counsel to discuss a schedule for the production of documents, and counsel conferred on May 16, and again on May 23 and June 2, but were unable to reach an agreement. Pls.' Br. [DE-115] at 7; Def.'s Opp'n [DE-125] at 2-3. Plaintiffs served a Third Request for Production of Documents in the McKiver case on May 24 and in the Gillis case on June 6. Def.'s Opp'n [DE-125] at 4. On May 31, Defendant responded to Plaintiffs' First RFPs by producing 601 documents (9,318 pages), directing Plaintiffs to 48,000 pages of documents already produced in preliminary discovery, and indicating it would produce additional responsive documents on a rolling basis with the production fully completed within thirty days. Pls.' Br. [DE-115] at 2-3; Def.'s Opp'n [DE-125] at 3. On June 7, Defendant produced an additional 5,000 pages. Def.'s Opp'n [DE-125] at 3. The parties have continued to confer regarding appropriate search terms, and on June 7 Plaintiffs provided Defendant with a revised list of 118 search terms that resulted in roughly 400,000 documents for review. Id. at 3-4. *2 Plaintiffs ask the court to compel production of the paper and ESI discovery immediately, asserting that responses were due from Defendant on May 31 and Defendant's rolling production violates the court's scheduling order and Rules 29 and 34 of the Federal Rules of Civil Procedure. Pls.' Br. [DE-115] at 2-9. Additionally, Plaintiffs ask the court to shorten from thirty to seven business days the notice requirement for 30(b)(6) depositions, reasoning that the delay in production has hampered Plaintiffs' ability to schedule these depositions. Id. at 9. Defendant responds that it has fully complied with Rule 34, which contemplates rolling productions, and that its production schedule is reasonable in light of Plaintiffs' burdensome discovery requests. Def. ’s Opp'n [DE-125] at 4-6. Defendant requests Plaintiffs' motion be denied and that the court enter a protective order pursuant to Rule 37(a)(5)(B) limiting the scope of Plaintiffs' RFPs and awarding Defendant its costs and fees in responding to Plaintiffs' motion. Id. at 8-10. Rule 37 of the Federal Rules of Civil Procedure provides that “[a] party seeking discovery may move for an order compelling an answer, designation, production, or inspection” if a party fails to produce or make available for inspection requested documents under Rule 34. Fed. R. Civ. P. 37(a)(3)(B)(iv). “[T]he court has ‘substantial discretion’ to grant or deny motions to compel discovery.” English v. Johns, No. 5:11-CT-3206-D, 2014 WL 555661, at *4 (E.D.N.C. Feb. 11, 2014) (unpublished) (quoting Lone Star Steakhouse & Saloon, Inc. v. Alpha of Va., Inc., 43 F.3d 922, 929 (4th Cir. 1995)). Rule 34 governs requests for production of documents. The rule provides generally that “[t]he party to whom the request is directed must respond in writing within 30 days after being served ....” Fed. R. Civ. P. 34(b)(2)(A). However, the rule also more specifically provides that “[t]he responding party may state that it will produce copies of documents or of electronically stored information instead of permitting inspection” and “[t]he production must then be completed no later than the time for inspection specified in the request or another reasonable time specified in the response.” Fed. R. Civ. P. 34(b)(2)(B). Here, Defendant responded to Plaintiffs' First RFPs on May 31, within thirty days of service as required by Rule 34(b)(2)(A) and the court's April 11, 2016 Interim Scheduling Order, which provides that “[w]ithin 30 days of service, Defendant shall serve responses to any such written discovery requests served by the Plaintiffs,” [DE-96-1] ¶ 17. See Def.'s Obj. & Resp. to McKiver's First RFPs [DE-115-2], In response to certain requests, Defendant stated that it would “produce any additional documents responsive to the request currently in Murphy-Brown's possession, custody and control, as limited by the asserted objection, with these responses and then on a rolling basis such that production is fully completed within thirty days.” Id. at 3-4 ¶ 1. This type of response is appropriate under Rule 34(b)(2)(B), and the April 11, 2016 Interim Scheduling Order contains a provision, negotiated by the parties and approved by the court, which contemplates such a response. With regard to document requests, the parties will meet and confer on a schedule for the full production of documents following service of the requests for production and an evaluation of their scope, in the event that the requests are believed by Defendant to entail significant time or labor, and Defendant shall initiate any such meet-and-confer process. [DE-96-1] ¶ 18. Additionally, given the number and breadth of the RFPs, the court finds that a rolling production over an additional thirty-day period is a “reasonable time.” Fed. R. Civ. P. 34(b)(2)(B). The actions taken by Defendant, as set forth in the affidavit of its lead discovery counsel, demonstrate reasonable diligence in responding to Plaintiffs' RFPs. Waylett Dec l. [DE-126]. Nevertheless, this ruling should not be read to imply that such a time frame would necessarily be reasonable in responding to RFPs going forward, where it is anticipated that efficiencies will be generated by the review process put in place by Defendant in responding to the First RFPs. Plaintiffs raise legitimate concerns regarding the ability to adhere to the court's scheduling order. However, the court is confident in the parties' ability to work cooperatively to complete discovery within the confines of the schedule set by the court and, therefore, finds it unnecessary to alter the notice requirement for 30(b)(6) depositions at this time. Accordingly, Plaintiffs' motion is denied.[1] *3 In response to Plaintiffs' motion, Defendant requests that the court enter a protective order pursuant to Rule 37(a)(5)(B) limiting the scope of Plaintiffs' RFPs and seeks an award of expenses. Def.'s Opp'n [DE-125] at 8-10. While generally a request for a court order must be made by motion, Fed. R. Civ. P. 7(b)(1), if a motion to compel is denied, “the court may issue any protective order authorized under Rule 26(c)....” Fed. R. Civ. P. 37(a)(5)(B). However, under the circumstances presented here, the court finds that Defendant's request is more appropriately made by separate motion rather than in a response brief given that the parties have raised somewhat disparate issues, i.e., Plaintiffs' motion addresses the timing of the production of documents while Defendant seeks a protective order related to substantive objections to certain discovery requests. Additionally, because replies to discovery motions are not allowed under Local Civil Rules 7.1(f)(2) and 26.1(d)(3), the issues raised by Defendant have not been fully briefed. Finally, the court declines to award expenses pursuant to Rule 37(a)(5)(B) as it finds Plaintiffs' position was substantially justified given the legitimate concern regarding adherence to the court's scheduling order. B. Motion to Compel the Production of Smithfield Foods, Inc. Documents Under Defendant's Control [DE-117] Plaintiffs' First and Second RFPs sought responsive documents from Defendant's “parent and subsidiary companies.” Pls.' Br., Ex. 1 [DE-118-1] at 3-4[2] (defining “you” and “your” to include parent and subsidiary companies, specifically including Murphy Brown, LLC, John Morrell & Co., Smithfield Foods, Inc., Shuanghui International Holdings Limited, Sun Merger Sub, Inc., and WH Group Limited). Defendant objected to, among other things, producing documents from Smithfield Foods, Inc. (“Smithfield”), because it would require Defendant “to provide information not in its possession, custody, or control.” Id., Ex. 2 [DE-118-2] at 3-4. Counsel for the parties engaged in the requisite meet-and-confer process, but were unable to resolve the issue. Id. [DE-122] at 1. Plaintiffs ask the court to find that Defendant has control over documents in the possession of Smithfield and to compel production of such responsive documents. Id. at 1-2. Plaintiffs assert, citing corporate filings and internal documents, that Defendant and Smithfield “have had a close, interconnected relationship since 2000” and that a 2015 corporate restructuring resulted in the absorption of Defendant into Smithfield so that there is no longer a distinction between the two. Id. at 3-10. Defendant responds that it lacks control over and has no legal right to documents in the possession of Smithfield. Defs.' Opp'n [DE-131] at 6-7. Defendant asserts it is owned by John Morrell & Co., which is a wholly-owned subsidiary of Smithfield, making Defendant a “corporate grandchild” of Smithfield and that Defendant and Smithfield do not use the same servers. Id. Defendant additionally argues that the documents are available to Plaintiffs through a subpoena to Smithfield (and Plaintiffs have in fact served such subpoenas) and that Plaintiffs' motion should be denied on proportionality grounds pursuant to Rule 26(b)(1). Id. at 5, 9-10. Rule 34 requires the production of discoverable evidence within the possession, custody, or control of the party. Fed. R. Civ. P. 34(a). Documents are deemed to be within the possession, custody, or control of a party if the party has actual possession, custody, or control or the legal right to obtain the documents on demand. See Bleecker v. Standard Fire Ins. Co., 130 F. Supp. 2d 726, 739 (E.D.N.C. 2000) (“[I]n order for the material to be discoverable, defendant must have some type of legal right to the material plaintiff seeks to discover.”). This court has declined to adopt an “ability to obtain” test in determining control because “[w]hen information is readily attainable through a subpoena duces tecum, no compelling reason exists to expand the definition of control.” Id. The “party seeking production of documents bears the burden of establishing the opposing party's control over those documents.” Prodigious Ventures, Inc. v. YBE Hosp. Grp., LLC, No. 5:14-CV-433-F, 2016 WL 1248806, at *4 (E.D.N.C. Mar. 25, 2016) (unpublished) (citations omitted). *4 Plaintiffs have asserted facts that could support a finding that Smithfield exercises some control over Defendant. See Pls.' Br. [DE-122] at 3-10 (e.g., Smithfield and Murphy-Brown have a “parent-subsidiary relationship”; Smithfield “controls every stage of pig production” through vertical integration with Murphy-Brown; Smithfield employees have corresponded with the North Carolina Department of Environment & Natural Resources on Murphy-Brown letterhead; WH Group, which owns Smithfield, implemented a corporate restructuring and Smithfield now controls the hog-production segment formerly controlled by Murphy-Brown; employees with Smithfield email addresses communicated internally about this litigation and with growers at issue in this litigation; and Smithfield's Form 10-K lists these cases as lawsuits it is defending). The court in Bleecker observed that “[r]elationships which evidence a legal right of a party to obtain a document from [a] non-party include ... a parent company from a subsidiary company.” Bleecker, 130 F. Supp. 2d at 739. However, the dispositive question here is whether Murphy-Brown, the subsidiary, has the “legal right to obtain the documents on demand” from Smithfield, the parent (once removed), not whether Smithfield has the legal right to obtain the documents from Murphy-Brown. Id.; see also Ehrlich v. BMW of N. Am., LLC, No. CV 10-1151-ABC PJWX, 2011 WL 3489105, at *1 (C.D. Cal. May 2, 2011) (unpublished) (concluding plaintiff failed to establish defendant BMW NA had legal control over documents in related corporation BMW AG's files where “BMW NA is owned by a company that is owned by BMW AG” and “nothing about this relationship suggests that BMW NA has the power to order BMW AG to turn over documents to BMW NA”; rejecting practical-ability-to-obtain test and plaintiff's argument that BMW NA must have access to the documents based on the inherent relationship between the companies). Moreover, Defendant provided a declaration from its Vice President of Finance and Information Technology stating, among other things, that none of the current officers or employees of Murphy-Brown are officers of Smithfield, Murphy-Brown maintains its own corporate records, Murphy-Brown and Smithfield utilize separate servers for document maintenance, and Murphy-Brown does not have access to Smithfield's servers or to the email of Smithfield employees. Lee Decl. [DE-132] ¶¶ 18-22. The court has also considered the fact that Defendant and Smithfield are represented by common outside counsel. Pls.' Br. [DE-122] at 6, n.23. This fact would carry greater weight under a practical-ability-to-obtain analysis, Uniden Am. Corp. v. Ericsson Inc., 181 F.R.D. 302, 306-07 (M.D.N.C. 1998) (citing M.L.C., Inc. v. N. Am. Philips Corp., 109 F.R.D. 134, 136 (S.D.N.Y. 1986)), but is less germane in determining whether Murphy-Brown has a legal right to documents on demand from Smithfield, the test adopted by this court, Bleecker, 130 F. Supp. 2d at 739. Finally, there is no dispute that the information sought by Plaintiffs is “readily attainable through a subpoena,” id., and Plaintiffs have, in fact, served a subpoena on Smithfield, Pls.' Br. [DE-122] at 10 n.43. Therefore, under the circumstances presented, the court need not “expand the definition of control.” Bleecker, 130 F. Supp. 2d at 739. Thus, the court concludes Plaintiffs have failed to demonstrate that Defendant can require Smithfield to turn over the documents sought. Accordingly, Plaintiffs' motion is denied. III. CONCLUSION For the reasons set forth above, Plaintiffs' Motion to Compel Discovery of Documents and Electronically Stored Information [DE-114] and Motion to Compel the Production of Smithfield Foods, Inc. Documents Under Defendant's Control [DE-117] are DENIED. SO ORDERED, the 1 day of July 2016. Footnotes [1] Plaintiffs' request for a telephonic hearing is denied as unnecessary to the determination of the motion. See Local Civil Rule 7.1 (i) (“Hearings on motions may be ordered by the court in its discretion. Unless so ordered, motions shall be determined without a hearing.”). [2] Unless otherwise indicated, the citations reference the page number assigned by CM/ECF as opposed to the document's internal page number where, as here, they differ.